How about a simple scheme where software producers can register their .exe with Microsoft and when I download an exe I could verify that the fingerprint of the exe is registered on the Microsoft whitelist? Or is this kind of thing already happening by the Defender?
I have never seen a message saying "Defender does not recognize this application, are you sure you want to start it?"
Also there's a lot of downloadable Open Source software where users are asked to "verify the keys". Couldn't Windows do this kind of thing automatically, or at least make it easy?