I was the quiet "science and math" kid in class but took high school speech and debate to round out my experience to get into college. I discovered how much I liked getting up in front of people and talking/arguing. Turns out, I was good at it and won a couple trophies. It was one of the most helpful things I did in high school.
I haven't tried Toastmasters, but I hear it's a great way to practice speaking to groups