Aside from legitimate scientific disagreement, there is also the very human political phenomenon of anti-authoritarianism, in which there is a segment of the population that is predisposed to oppose government mandates of any kind, but particularly where they cannot directly observe the problem the mandates are designed to address. Most people in most places, at least here in the US, never directly experienced the kind of emergency that public pandemic policy was designed to avoid. Depending on your point of view, you can regard that as a success of the policy, or evidence that the policy wasn't needed. I think given the examples of places like northern Italy where the virus raged largely unabated, that the best evidence suggests that the former is the case.
That's an easier ask when we have reason to trust the CDC, Dr. Fauci etc. But when they embrace the concept of "the noble lie", that will obviously lead to people not trusting them.
They absolutely did - https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/20/health/covid-cdc-data.htm...
"We are not sure how much protection masks do offer, but if you want to be cautious it is highly recommended to wear them and we are looking to mandate use in certain locations out of caution".
Would not be too difficult and summoning a ghost just induces more mistrust. Another advantage of being honest here is that you can recall that policy without losing face. It also does not induce unrealistic expectations which will haunt you on other policies.
> there is also the very human political phenomenon of anti-authoritarianism, in which there is a segment of the population that is predisposed to oppose government mandates of any kind
I don't really see the disadvantages here to be honest and they wouldn't have much room for opposition.
The obvious potential disadvantage of a knee-jerk reaction against authority in an emergency is that many could die because a few people opposed any mandate out of misplaced principle. Whether you think that is relevant in this case depends on whether you understand what the true dangers were. I think most of the people opposed to masking and vaccine mandates simply never understood the epidemic beyond the immediate threat it presented to themselves personally. And of course public officials are responsible for a much bigger picture.