I mean theoretically how much would you be willing to pay for search that has no advertisement.
$1000 a year?
I'm genuinely curious, what would a privacy first non-advertising based approach cost? I mean I suspect you could discount it by not tracking individual users but instead just advertise on results searched, but what does the extreme version of this cost like do you think?
What kind of money do we need to put on the table that someone serving it goes, you know what, let's just provide a great search product, if we start trying to mess around with ads / tracking, we're risking killing this golden goose?
But there are definitely people who are genuinely interested in paying.
Even facebook does provide me with some benefit, but less at present than Alphabet does, though maybe with Oculus that will change?
This isn't novel work, and is likely even cheaper than the dead tree variant. The most expensive parts are the hardware and storage costs for the index.
That's like a return to yahoo directory / search index.
Or were you imagining something different?
The major issue that may hold it back though, is libraries wouldn't sacrifice their current duties and role in society to do it, (which I agree with wholeheartedly). and anyone trying to host an honest search index is going to have to deal with the political baggage associated therewith. If you host for profit, you will get sued. If you did it as a research project/labor of love (from the United States), arguably, you may have grounds to tell other people's lawyers to stuff it, but there are certain interests which will spend every hour and minute they can trying to get the courts to twist your arm into preserving the integrity of their business model. The law os also fraught with precedent that makes things like pirate site listing a no-no; but it is not clear to my knowledge if that is a blanket ban on indexing, or a ban on indexing + any type of amplification while reaping financial benefit thereby.
I've contemplated doing a project in that direction a few times. I always end up waffling before I get started though. I'd totally do it, but I have a feeling I'd better get a JD first unless I essentially want a hobby project to turn into some lawyer's recreational revenue stream. It's sad it's come to that, but it is what is.
It is definitely on my list of "Stuff to do once I've built myself up a nest egg". As I truly think an index unpoisoned by commercial concerns is something the world expected, and increasingly needs. I weep for a return to a more objective picture of the Web; one where it was in a literal sense more the worlds hypertext implemented phonebook rather than a cesspool of SEO garbage, and lawsuit driven optics management/platforming tool.
It just blows, because the moment you start getting people to help stave off what operational costs are incurred, and it goes beyond donation/volunteerism, you're done. Somebody will have an in to coerce you into distorting your search index. If not on commercial interest, then on the basis that of course, "some arsehole will host CP (or other verboten content) out there, and what do when you index it?"
I may be a militant enough "info must be free" personality to undertake the journey... But I'm one person, and my interest is prone to fickleness, and I've been called an absolute madman by enough people I have the feeling that if things did get off the ground sufficiently, I am unsure whether or not I'd find someone else willing to work on keeping the thing available.
And there are few things I hate in life more than being a Single Point Of Failure.
Alphabet's total revenue in 2021 was about $257B. If, say, a billion users paid an average of $257 a year, that would be the same annual revenue. That doesn't seem at all unreasonable (less than $22 a month for actual services for me as a user unadulterated by ads and without privacy concerns? where do I sign up?), particularly since if they were just providing services users actually need--search, maps, gmail, etc.--and not having to add on all the extra effort of advertising, it would be cheaper for them to provide those services to users than it is now.
As a comparison, I've paid for Spotify for a long time primarily to get rid of ads and was entirely ok with that.
I certainly pay for dev tools on a yearly basis that cost me a similar level as $257 a year and so I feel like paying for what Alphabet offer in terms of map / video / search fits comfortably in that same bracket of cost to value that I'd be ok making that trade as well.
I don't know if I'd pay themselves Alphabet that much, primarily because like with they Youtube example, what kind of a commitment[1] could they make that makes me believe that me paying them would mean they stop treating me as a product and as a customer instead? It sort of feels like that ship sailed a long time ago, ad money is very seductive it seems.
- [0]: It also doesn't help that their recommendation engine seems to give worse recommendations over time, so a regular purge seems to be required to get back to reasonable recommendations.
- [1]: This ends up being a fun thought experiment.
I'm not sure they could make a credible commitment to that at this point. I'm not sure there is any viable way for them to transition, at scale, from their current business model to one where they just charge users directly for services those users want. But the latter business model is still there, waiting, and sooner or later I think someone will find a way to use it to take Google's market.
What I want is some fixed revenue-sharing service a la YouTube Premium but for the entire Internet. Pay $XX/month, and get access to a zillion websites, with each one receiving revenue proportional to how much you use it.
Except the websites would probably game that by loading a zillion empty iframes or something. Damn.
Let's say the average searches per day is 4 and they are general enough queries to be showing ads, of which there are an average of 3 per page. It would be a mix of CPM and clicks, but each placement will average out to roughly $0.007 in revenue. That's 360 ads per month resulting in ~$2.50 per user.
Of course, that doesn't include the specific overhead of brokering the ads or developing and maintaining such a bizarrely complicated system, and it's safe to assume their margins are at most 20-30%. So, after expending all of that effort in creating this anti-privacy, anti-consumer, anti-competitive system that's rigged against both the advertisers and users, they're making a whopping $0.75/mo per search user.
Which is all to say that if search were simply search, then they could: charge $10/year for an ad-free and privacy-focused service, drastically simplify their entire infrastructure, reassign the ad support staff toward much-needed consumer issues, and actually be making more money in the process. However, this doesn't include Maps or other services, which is how they convert that $0.75/mo search user into a $10/mo ecosystem addict (or $1,000/mo supporter of content creators).
Search is the method for directing traffic where they want it to go, and the trick is to also be making money from all of those places, with even more profitable ads or salable products. I think any search engine will struggle with this when it inevitably grows beyond its core product, because the alternative is a mess of different companies, products, APIs and methodologies that barely work together -- moral high ground wages aren't exactly an ingredient for explosive, cohesive and industry-competitive innovation.
- You're completely discounting the overhead of running a $10/mo service, not to mention the cost of acquisition.
- Google and other free-to-use search engines aren't going away in this scenario, so this hypothetical paid search engine will need to "compete with free"
- If you're competing with free, you need to offer a better experience than the free service. Cutting the BS sounds good, but is it $10/mo better than the free service?
Finally, the biggest issue is that, with the ad model, the minimum Google earns per user is $0.75/mo, but they could make notably more off of negotiated deals for big purchases (eg: Google could sell placements against high-dollar things like real estate for more money) or could just get a windfall from high-frequency months; with your model, the maximum the business can ever earn is $10/mo.
You're entirely misreading what I said. They already have the service and that is an existing cost. To have the ads is an additional cost (and a massive one at that), which could be entirely replaced with a virtually zero-cost purchase form. That's less overhead, not equal -- and certainly not more. Also, I specifically referenced the overhead in my comment, so it's amazing that you would claim I'm disregarding it.
> Google and other free-to-use search engines aren't going away in this scenario, so this hypothetical paid search engine will need to "compete with free"
I literally used Google as an example of how they could make more money without ads, and I didn't say anything at all about them only having a paid option. Also, my conclusion was that paid can't compete with free, so you just reiterated my point in an attempt to "prove me wrong."
> If you're competing with free, you need to offer a better experience than the free service. Cutting the BS sounds good, but is it $10/mo better than the free service?
I said $10/year, not $10/mo. Is $1/mo worth it from a user perspective to remove ads and privacy invasive features? The universal answer to that for any employed individual is yes (even if they've been tricked into thinking otherwise), because all of these companies have repeatedly proven that they can't be trusted to monetize free services without acting incredibly harmful in the process.
> Finally, the biggest issue is that, with the ad model, the minimum Google earns per user is $0.75/mo, but they could make notably more off of negotiated deals for big purchases (eg: Google could sell placements against high-dollar things like real estate for more money) or could just get a windfall from high-frequency months; with your model, the maximum the business can ever earn is $10/mo.
I said that $0.75 was the average, not the minimum, and that was already based on an average of all of the higher and lower term rates. If users are contributing $0.75/mo on average via ads, then a switch to paying $1/mo averages out to more revenue. That's how averages work.
And again, my conclusion was that paid doesn't actually beat free from the amoral business perspective, so all you're doing is agreeing with me while also trying to tell me I'm wrong (based on things nobody said).
I should be able to share my 'shitlist' with other users and see the rank of my shitlist domains that are included on other's shitlist.