Just look at the past 100 years. We have observably created tremendous value since 1922. We can make the whole pie bigger, it’s not just one set “value” pie that never changes.
Just look at the past 100 years. We have observably created tremendous value since 1922. We can make the whole pie bigger, it’s not just one set “value” pie that never changes.
The argument/debate described in TFA is that we may or do need to escape from this cycle; my point was that if Graeber's argument is correct, this is made all the more difficult by the presence of interest-bearing debt.
If there's inflation but no corresponding increase in the monetary supply, it becomes more difficult (in aggregate) to pay for things, which means that "actual economic growth" becomes necessary to pay the debt.
If there's inflation and a corresponding increase in the monetary supply (e.g. where banks just print money and prices rise, in either order), then (in theory) paying off the debt becomes easier.
If there's an increase in the monetary supply but no inflation, then (in theory) paying off the debt becomes easier.
However, all these scenarios are unusual: in general, inflation is assumed to be controlled, and roughly known, and the interest rate will already include the assumed rate of inflation. When things go upside down w.r.t. inflation, you can certainly get unusual conditions around debt. But that's not the normal situation, even when there is actual inflation.