America Has a Free Speech Problem
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Criticism is not a problem with free speech -- criticism is free speech. In most situations, retaliation isn't, either. You may not like it, but nothing about free speech guarantees you the freedom from consequences, except from the government itself.
There is a very serious problem, that we've grown very hostile with each other, and would rather fight than work together. That's not a problem with the speech, but with our attitudes to our national life. You will not fix them by any tinkering with rules about what is and isn't allowed when somebody talks.
There are legit uses here. Margeret Hamilton being unable to use the computer[1] after the Midnight Computer Wiring Society came in & took the right to rewire the mainframe themselves, denying her her own positive right to compute/freedom from unexpectedly changing systems (itcs kind of both? im undecided!) is an example I think of a lot, an important respin on a classic bit of positive-liberties denying others, an important omitted crucial conflict in a bit of cyberlore immortalized by Steven Levy's book Hackers.
Rights do conflict. Whether we head towards a society where things are permitting or denied is a balance I prefer being able to see open, but often this ends up depending on civil cooperation to function, rather than rights proportioned perfectly so.
[1] http://opentranscripts.org/transcript/programming-forgetting...
I've got my own fingers to point at who I believe is most responsible, and I don't believe that we'll make much progress until certain people choose to discuss things rather than treating their compatriots as enemies. But it's clear that doing so is an effective tactic for winning elections, especially if you can use the rules to your advantage.
So I'm afraid I don't know how to fix that. No system will be effective among people who consider themselves enemies.
"Criticism" is often essentially a threat to retaliation, or merely the heckler's veto [1].
[1]: e.g. https://www.foxnews.com/us/yale-law-students-bipartisan-free...
I will note that the author like many making "freedom of speech" arguments fundamentally mistakes what that means, at least in the context of US law.
American "freedom of speech" is specifically not the right to say whatever you please with absolutely no ramification, that people (not the government) listening to your speech have no right to react to it and thus ironically depriving the audience of their freedom of speech.
This is of course the "free speech" some want. The ability to voice their views/truths/lies and silence countering views/truths/lies as some sort of censorship of their original speech.
To be clear, this is not what "freedom of speech" in the US is or has ever been. I feel like the anonymity of internet speech has confused some into believing that all speech is fair game and that no speech should have a negative consequence.
"Left Wing Cancel Culture" is at it's core is a free speech reaction to someone else's free speech. This is fundamentally no different than "Right Wing Dog Piling" or voting in elections for that matter.
People can (within some generous limits) say what they want to say without fear that the government is going to arrest them. This is a great American Freedom as many living under totalitarian systems will tell you. People who do say what they want must accept that speech is fundamentally persuasive and that people will react to it. In fact, that was likely the entire motivation for the speech in the first place.
No place and certainly not the US has ever held that all speech is good speech and must be embraced without any negative reaction.
Tempted to downvote? You will only prove me right.