Ethics aside, I rather have a smart person in charge rather than the opposite
Ethics aside, I rather have a smart person in charge rather than the opposite
I have definitely seen hiring managers lean very hard on pedigree so they didn't have to do the actual work of evaluating candidates. It was basically the same deal with a lot of certifications, like Scrum/Agile and Java certs.
I also think that your bucketing people such that Harvard = smart and state school = "the opposite" is a great example of the problem. Personally, I'd always rather work with somebody who has had to work their way up, as they tend to have a more balanced perspective.
[1] E.g.: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/04/07/harvards-freshman-class-is-m...
As a business, you bet your risks against the person who has been vetted vs. the unproven one.
And anyway, you're again, not very smartly, ignoring the point that a fancy degree doesn't correlate particularly well with smartness, so the whole intelligence thing is a bit of a sideshow to the actual discussion here.
Simply having 1/3 of Harvard admissions being legacy does not disprove that those who go to Ivy Leagues are not intelligent. On the contrary, studies show that IQ is highly genetic (up to 80%). So it is just reasonable for admission offices to accept students based on family ties
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ#cite_note-B...
There is also a correlation between IQ, general intelligence and SAT scores (a requirement for admissions), despite what the media portrays.
FYI: Media is manipulated to create controversy and get views. Scientific studies are not perfect, but has far lower cases due to the peer review process, except for privately funded research
[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/labs/pmc/articles/PMC6963451/#B...
But what you're really dodging is the question of how much the very narrow sort characteristic tested by IQ really matters for hiring. I get that you think it's super important. Probably because you see yourself there. But as somebody in the top 1% of IQ scores, I'm telling you it's not a great way to select employees, and in many circumstances it can correlate negatively. You can use it for hiring if you want, and if you work for a competitor, I encourage you to. But I sure won't.
Employment is a separate matter, the follow up will be if leadership or management competence (different) is tied to intelligence and elite school attendance.
So, the issue is not one of smartness, as Harvard itself says in its reports, since majority of their applicants are smart anyway. That's how the filtering works for the super elite, and the 'servants' of this super elite--and this 'servant' class also also elite as well. Here, I am not using 'servant' in pejorative sense, but in the sense that one who works for super elite end up making millions a year.
My life is great, I am not trying to complain.
Elsewhere you asked for proof. There is plenty of proof that income is the best predictor for attending an ivy league school.
Here is an article from harvard: https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2020/06/at-home-with-harvard...
Harvard has almost as many students from the nation’s top 0.1 percent highest-income families as from the bottom 20 percent.