2 things: 1) Do returners have any knowledge of the reward value before they send it off? I can see it going two ways - someone not sending something in because of the value of the item vs reward or users trying to get away with the minimum payment of $50 because the other person doesn't know how much the reward will be.
Still, if someone had a sticker on something like this I'd probably return it regardless of the reward.
2) Typo on order page. "the'll hold up. "
I love the design of the stickers.
I could see an expansion being tamper proof stickers for an extra fee. Yours are laminated, but I might want something (for corporate assets or something) that can't be removed.