Massachusetts Toll Collectors Make An Average of $70,000/yr
boston.com
boston.com
If they had one lane setup where you could pick up a transponder and then activate it via the phone or Internet when you got home, I bet in a month nearly everyone in the state would have one.
Ultimately, even the transponders and phone-signup are superfluous. At least in the SF Bay area, there are license plate cameras which handle any case where the transponder fails or cars blow through without paying -- it's then added to your bill or mailed as a ticket.
So most lanes just need to be: "I agree to be billed according to my car registration."
With the one lane for people who want to pay cash.
The Turnpike Authority was chartered as an independent agency that could float bonds for road construction, and once the bonds were paid off, ownership of the Turnpike would pass to the state government. So the Authority keeps itself perpetually in debt.
Thank god. Having 2 lanes out of 8 be automated means that everyone just has to wait in traffic until those lanes open up right at the tolls, thus killing any time savings.
We continue to find ways to increase productivity and increase wealth.
But, there is increasingly little correlation between that and increases in wages. Or, perhaps, an inverse correlation.
We are probably misunderestimating the impact this is going to have on our society.
It's no longer as clear as it once seemed that steady increases in the standard of living for the common man can be taken as a given.
It's no longer as clear as it once seemed that steady increases in the standard of living for the common man can be taken as a given.
Well, that depends. If we have overestimated the availability of finite resources, that is true. But just saying so isn't enough -- to be taken seriously, you should rephrase your belief as something like "As my long energy, long basic materials, and short consumer discretionaries portfolio demonstrates, I believe that higher prices for energy and basic materials, coupled with lower average wages, will reduce the standard of living and thus reduce consumption of non-essential goods." And there's a catch-22, here: if you and all the other people who talk that way are also investing that way, energy and basic materials prices will rise, to the point that balance is restored.
Hmmm.
There is always something to do for less skilled workers, so there's nothing wrong with automation.
How would that be unfortunate?
http://www.reason.com/news/show/122019.html
The public often literally believes that labor is better to use than conserve.
Ultimately any cost savings could be passed back to the taxpayers.
The job is worth minimum wage ($12,000 / yr or so) at best. In a free market, you could find folks who would work this job at that price.
Some of these folks have so few skills that they would still work this job.
Other of these folks have higher skills, and isntead of using them in some productive role (manager at a pharmacy, etc.), they're wasting their skills sitting on a stool making change.
If you think that it's a good thing for unskilled labor to be paid - because of union monopolization of labor - far far above it's productive level, then why not make the minimum wage $70k/yr for everyone?
Or better yet, $120k/yr ?
A labor-market with a minimum wage is not a free market. In a free market, you could find folks who would work this job at one dollar per hour. But how could they afford to live? "Basic income" (unconditional trickle-capital) and deregulated construction and real-estate (e.g. $60/month apartments in major markets).
I'm intrigued with the idea of the government just delivering a bucket of money to every household once a year.
An advantage is that you place some sort of floor under everyone's income, that would mitigate against basic poverty issues like homelessness, no money for food or health care, etc. Another advantage is that everyone still has the same incentives to work, because they can get ahead without worrying about losing their assistance from being too successful. And (bringing back to HN) having certain necessities taken care of could enable risk taking and entrepeneurship. Basically, the government paying for you ramen noodles, instead of pg :).
I know there are lots of potential problems with this idea, but I've seen it proposed before, and think it makes a good starting point for a discussion of thinking of things like poverty, minimum wage, health care, etc. in a different way.
An advantage is that you place some sort of floor under everyone's income, that would mitigate against basic poverty issues like homelessness, no money for food or health care, etc. Another advantage is that everyone still has the same incentives to work
Hmmm. That sounds like what I just wrote. Here is the link again:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income
I know there are lots of potential problems with this idea
Actually, there are not any problems with it. A capitalist society cannot function on a healthy level without universal no-strings-attached trickle-capital. However, I am interested in finding out what you find wrong with the idea.
Thanks for the link! Interesting to see Alaska mentioned as an example of this idea, especially given current political discussions.
They could all learn programming and then they would earn closer to $130K/year, I suppose, but does that make it relevant to HN?
How do you figure? Do high-IQ people normally become toll-collectors?
1. First sentence: Cookie-cutter bitch about On-topicness.
2. Second sentence: Two incorrect assumptions. a) They "all" could learn programming, and b) that they would then make closer to 130K/year.
3. Second sentence (part 2): Another cookie-cutter bitch about On-topicness.
Replacing toll workers with automated systems may save money, and may be inevitable, and trust me, I have quite a fascination with robots, but still, I am sorry for those hapless humans in their way.
Don't worry! If you really care about reintroducing useless inefficiency by paying people to do things a robot could do instead, there are plenty of outlets for your passion. For example, why not hire someone to transcribe your email by hand, instead of writing it directly? All the benefits of useless labor, but taxpayers don't feel disgruntled about it!