Who Gets Self-Determination?
astralcodexten.substack.com
astralcodexten.substack.com
Similarly, this stance implies that regions within sovereign nations do not have the unilateral right to declare independence, as doing so would change the current international borders. (This often leads to war when existing states are unwilling to cede territory).
>> Somebody’s going to ask “but what about the Confederacy?” The position that most tempts me is “The Confederacy had every right to secede, because every region that wants to secede has that right - but immediately upon granting them independence, the Union should have invaded in order to stop the atrocity of slavery”.
I won't make any claims about what the US "should" have done in the 1860's when the Confederacy declared independence, but I will note a few key points. Firstly, Confederate troops opened fire on US military positions, commencing the outbreak of hostilities. Secondly, the United States had by that point a storied history of seizing the lands of its neighbors for expansion (in accordance with the idea of manifest destiny). See, for example, the Mexican-American war. It is, then, hardly any surprise that the US chose to use its larger military, population, and industry to conquer a smaller neighbor that had limited transportation infrastructure and almost no foreign allies.
War is an essential form of conflict resolution. War should be avoided, but not at the expense of allowing intractable situations to fester. My parents’ generation went to war to secure a country for our ethnic group (Bengalis). It was a good thing—we managed to get out of Pakistan before it’s slow descent into being a failed state. Your principle would have caused a bad situation to get worse.
Andrey Kurkov, an Ukrainian writer born in the same city as Putin, who writes mainly in Russian, thinks differently. See after 5:00.