But if we don't observe that complete control (at least not in most species), and instead it's more of an "arms race"; then it makes me think complete control is an evolutionary disadvantage. Is that true?
But if we don't observe that complete control (at least not in most species), and instead it's more of an "arms race"; then it makes me think complete control is an evolutionary disadvantage. Is that true?
If a female duck had complete control, genetic variety would likely decrease quickly as fewer, genetically similar males fathered all the children. This group of ducks would be more susceptible to disease, genetic defects, etc.
It could also be the case that if male ducks can’t be certain who the father is, they are more likely to help protect/not kill the young.
That is to say, sexual evolution increasingly approximates a globally optimal process, as an aggregate system of autonomous agents.
The Internet is also not actually a global network. It's just lots of local connections between two computers. Yet the effect approaches a global network.
It seems obvious to me (from logic and observation) that most animals don’t have global connectivity (despite your comparison to internet meshes), and obviously evolve differently across the world.
Virii, for example, transfer genes between species. Bacteria have plasmids, rings of genes they can literally just give to other bacteria.
As for an example where you know the global optima: real life hill climbing rather than the blindfolded version used to explain the algorithm of the same name?
Would you care to name a few?
I don’t immediately see it, unless we assume that the male genitalia stops adapting to whatever the female has.
The strategy is not fundamentally stable; female bedbugs have no genitalia at all but that doesn't give them any control.
Have you considered that every specie approaches this differently for their own situations? That doesn’t mean it’s a conceptual failure.