Comment by bodge5000 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by bodge5000 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

For me at least, the problem comes in with when you ask for a donation.

When I first downloaded Godot, I didn't donate because I had no idea if I'd even use it for long. After a year or so of using it, I came across various reminders to donate, and eventually I did (if I'm completely honest, literally just now). But most people will never come across that prompt again and will forget any need to. Its the same case with Elementary, or any other distro I've tried out. Why pay if I dont know if I'll even use it?

That being said, I can't think of any better way of asking without being obtrusive to the user. I guess you could have some really pointless badge or something you unlock by donating which could help prompt users later down the line, but I cant imagine the FOSS community would be a big supporter of that.

elementary's daily/preview builds are only accessible to GitHub sponsors over a certain amount. I wonder how that worked out, because I like this pseudo-subscription model a lot better, and wish AppCenter could even figure out that I'm a supporter and redistribute some of my $$$ to apps that I often use.

I would have happily paid them to add a "minimize window" button. Frankly, that's the only think I was ever missing while using E. on my main Linux laptop for the last two years.

It has been a pretty slick experience, and that's remarkable given the general state of Linux on the desktop (admittedly, I may be more of a command line person, but still).

So maybe instead of "donate", try "pay for getting your very own feature implemented"?

> So maybe instead of "donate", try "pay for getting your very own feature implemented"?

1. If you're effectively hiring a developer to work on a custom feature for you, including the future costs of maintenance and code complexity, the price is going to be very high.

2. The lack of a minimize button was a UX decision. You can disagree with the decision, but if elementary implemented every feature that people with money requested, you probably wouldn't like the resulting UI. Or maybe you would, but elementary would be a very different sort of distro.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com