Success isn’t down to free will – luck determines everything
theguardian.com
theguardian.com
Based on the title, my interpretation is that the author would like individuals to discount their own success and be more empathetic to those less successful. However, an individual's capacity for empathy and their views on success factors, etc. are also luck based by this rationale. So it seems that the logical conclusion from this line of reasoning is an individual can't do anything other than what they're already doing, so can't ultimately be held responsible.
To be clear, I'm not suggesting the argument is wrong, just that the moral of the article (based on its focus on success) seems at conflict with the logic it is based on.
Responsibility is an idea inside a person (it's an ethical concept), not a law of nature.
As such, if the person doesn't have free will (and can't act on his independent volition) then they also can't remove their feeling/belief about responsibility. If it's there (and for most people it is), it's there.
Deterministic causual chains of the type we're talking about don't allow for responsibily. One thing merely causes another, going back to the Bing Bang, without any flexibility of it being otherwise or anybody chosing to do anything else.
If you have no choice, you have no responsibility, not in any moral sense. You only have "responsibility" in a deterministic universe if we use "responsible" as a synonym for "caused" (as in, X's action is "responsible" for this happening. But that's no more of a responsibility, character/person/morally -wise, as saying "the rain is responsible for the road being wet").
That's not only true for a deterministic universe with no free will/choice. We also accept it in our legal system, even while believing in free will.
For example, if somebody does something because they have no other choice, e.g. because somebody else put a gun to their head to do it, we don't consider them responsible, or at least we consider them much less responsible than when acting on their own
We're arguing over semantics, which definition is "more right". My opinion as a bioscientist is that there is no other proper definition that lines up with the deterministic reality of the universe. Some causes are just too complex for us to understand currently so we write it off as " personal responsibility"
Just because we wrote something in law doesn't make it correct. Humans are dumb as shit.
1. In order to survive, you to take a less than ideal job, but you still have the responsibility to do your duty to the best of your ability.
2. You had a wedlock child not of your planning. You still are responsible for the child.
3. For Nazi Germany soldiers, "I was just following orders" is not a valid excuse. You have a conscience and are responsible for you actions.
The people who believe in "choice" are precisely the ones who don't want to take responsibility for their actions - ex: "my body, my choice" in vaccines or abortion. The brainwashing propaganda runs very deep.
The reality is that you don't really have a no choice in anything - you only think you do, but you are still responsible to do right under your conditions
So I cannot prove whether free-will exists or does not. But I believe it's quite logical to say that to argue otherwise would be pointless and irrational.
And I do understand that the downvoters feel that they were clearly forced to do it by a complex and indelible series of events going back at least billions of years. :)
Case A: no free will really exists. We reason about whether free will exists. We conclude it does not.
Case B: free will really exists. We reason about whether free will exist. We conclude it does.
Do you think society A and society B march on exactly the same?
because everything is pointless then - it's already happened, it's known. done. You are a puppet on a string and have no free-will.
As I said, to argue that free will does not exist is a pointless waste of time. Disingenuous. If you are right, then it's obviously true - but why argue because you know that you'll change nothing. The truth is the same a million years ago and a million years hence. So to argue the point implies you are just not honestly debating and not considering the merits and arguments or trying to convince. You must acede that you are not in a fair debate.
If you are wrong, well, then I can accept that. You may be wrong and there could be change!
To argue, even reason, is either (free-will) to effect change, or (no-free-will) a waste of time. The later of which is illogical and irrational - simply a belief and an action with nothing more.
It's a tautological falsehood to debate or question free will. The mere action of debate and reason implies will.
Again, this doesn't prove that free-will exists, but to me it proves illogical to argue against it.
But I do not need to win the point "pointless to do anything", sufficient is "pointless to debate".
If it is predestined, then it is simply not really a debate.
Such as we are doing here
Debate is simply an exchange of information between two entities, its our perception of what debate is that's incorrect
Same for whatever you feel.
If there's a deterministic universe, it includes your thoughts and feelings, not just "what happens" at large.
https://trendguardian.medium.com/free-will-a-rich-fairy-tale...
Doesn't matter. The arguing would happen (or not happen) anyway, because it, too, would be absolute and predetermined.
When people talk about predetermination and lack of free will, they always pause at some point, and talk as if you can have those together with some meta-discussion about them, or an handling (or at least appreciation) of them that's not affected by that predetermination and lack of free will.
I don't blame them for that, of course: they're predetermined to do so. I could have blamed them, of course, but I'm predetermined not to.
Of course! And this would make it a pointless and futile debate then. You might even be right, but you should not win a debate with "it's inevitable and predetermined".
I'm not so sure about that (but then, I would say so, no matter what).
For it to be pointless, something like a "thing having a point" / deeper meaning would have to exist, but none does in a predetermined universe. So, it's not pointless as opposed to pointful, it's in a universe devoid of point-ness altogether.
And in a sense it's not futile: in a deterministic cause/effect universe, having that argument is going to affect all future futures. If that argument didn't happen, the universe would still be deterministic (assuming it is to begin with), but the flow of events concerning the people having the argument and anything they affected would have changed.