I think Dunbar's number exemplifies a failing in our social science culture, or maybe our epistemological tendencies. .. or maybe it just shows what happens when MBA texbooks adopt something.
We don't really know what to do with a piece of insight or knowledge like Dunbar's number. When is it "true?" When is it relevant? What does it say about how we should organize? What does it say about how organisations of different sizes function? What kind of successes or failures does Dunbar's nunber suggest we encounter.
I'm not saying that Dunbar's number is wrong. I'm suggesting that for it to be profound in a scientific sense, it needs to have consequences. Prediction, prescription, insight about existing structures, something.
We intuitively agree that working at an 80 person company is different from an 800 person could company. I don't see Dunbar's theories adding much beyond that, no predictions or insights about how such organisations work.
Mostly it's a piece of theory that can be thrown onto slides, in support or objection to something as needed.
Is there a there, there? Do I have this wrong?