But they don't have so much utility that they should offer such returns on top of depreciation. The market is broken.
It's not the house that appreciates much in value, its the land the house sits on.
I'm aware. But the land mainly has so much value because cities refuse to expand despite the demand.
Expanding horizontally doesn't solve land price values -- prices will still be higher in the dense centre
The solution is to make better use of valuable land by encouraging (or enforcing) high density
Ok yes but even if this was a rental home and the renters basically paid the mortgage.. so you didn't get any utility out of it. 30 years later you made $200k, even if you put basically nothing down. As a return it's a lot percentage wise. Overall though, it's not life changing for most people. It only gets crazy money in the most desirable of areas. And that desire circle is basically described as driving range from the highest paying jobs.