After just 1 term he remarkably lost to Reagan. I just never quite understood why he lost so badly.
After just 1 term he remarkably lost to Reagan. I just never quite understood why he lost so badly.
Yes, I know the quote is paraphrased and was originally about Nixon. I just find this befuddlement why Jimmy Carter lost amusing.
Man got very badly played:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter%27s_engagement_wi...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1979_oil_crisis
He was also attacked by a bunny:
The fact that someone would bend over backwards to misinterpret a sensationalized incident with a wild animal as Carter "being played" says more about that person's preconceived political ideology than Carter's, and identifies them as one of Carter's "political and ideological opponents". How exactly does a swimming rabbit "play" a human being, or frame him as hapless and enfeebled?
>The incident with the rabbit became fodder for political and ideological opponents who wanted to frame Carter's presidency as hapless and enfeebled, although the event's proximity to the U.S. release of the comedy feature film Monty Python and the Holy Grail, which includes scenes of a killer rabbit slaying humans, led to some people describing Carter as having "fended off a killer rabbit" instead.
To get back to the actual point of this discussion, why do you believe that the sensationalized story about Carter "being attacked by a bunny" is more indicative of whether Carter was hapless, enfeebled, or getting played, than the objective historical fact that he bravely and selflessly risked his own life and health by saving a Canadian nuclear reactor after a meltdown?
Edit: I saw that. You just edited your comment to tell me that editing my comment (to add more information) is bad form, then you quickly edited your comment again to remove that remark after you remembered that was exactly what you were doing and have already done several times in this discussion, yourself (to change the meaning of your post). And that shows your intellectual dishonesty. So please stick to the discussion topic and reply to the points I raised, instead of hypocritically admonishing me not to do exactly what you've already just done repeatedly (like your "Racism bad" addendum -- we all already know that, but your original "So?" post sounded like you didn't believe that, so you had to add that obvious disclaimer, followed by more racism apologetic non-sequiturs, attempting to excuse Reagan's racism by pointing out that he used to be a Democrat). Denying and making excuses and carrying the water for racism is much worse form than editing comments, but "there you go again", to quote Reagan.
On the other hand, I'd rather spend my time watching and recommend other people watch stuff like this:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30969388
(For whatever reason, that's not available on youtube. My pet conspiracy theory about why not is that the Pepsi Corporation suppressed it because they don't want anyone to watch it! So I included a partial transcript to save you from being tracked and receiving targeted advertisements for watching it. ;) )
The video recuter linked above is a from Tom Scott. Tom Scott is not a skinhead or any other sort of racist.
Well that's certainly disingenuous of him to lie that it's a video of "judgmental British skinheads" then, isn't it?
I'm sorry you took the bait and watched the video, and it's nice for you that it wasn't a rick roll or something worse, but I have no desire to waste my finite time on Earth watching youtube videos of "judgmental British skinheads laughing their asses off", or for that kind of stuff to pollute my viewing history and recommendations, or to contribute to their ad revenue, so I gave him the benefit of the doubt, assumed good faith, and took his false claim at face value instead of presuming that he was simply lying.
HN Guideline: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."
My bad for being so trusting, but I'm in your debt for setting me straight that he's a liar.
But doesn't the fact you kindly shared that he lied just prove my point that he's not arguing in good faith, and is intellectually dishonest?
So now that you've selflessly subjected yourself to that video, what is it that YOU think it proves, besides my point that he's not arguing in good faith, and can't come up with a better argument?
At least I posted an accurate description and transcript to the video I linked to. Did you click through and watch that too?
In Canada we get taught more about the 1979 canadian embassy helped save the US diplomats.
It's interesting I found this link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1979_Iranian_Revolution_conspi...
If political wiki is calling it a conspiracy theory... it's probably true.
That's a great bunny story. Goes to show a political bias in the media even back then.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Carter_UFO_incident
Check out this. He publicly admitted to seeing a UFO. You might think he was a crackpot or something but suddenly the navy started revealing UFO videos.
https://www.space.com/ufos-videos-declassified-navy-release....
There's some high ranking elected us politicians who upon this coming out they said there's so much more still classified. Yet nobody is talking about this.
Just because the things that makes politicians successful don't make for particularly good people doesn't negate Carter's lack of proficiency in the field.
In the modern age this is even more apparent because of the media and how stupidly polarising it is compared to the era of Carter, Reagan and Nixon.
Best example that comes to mind is Kevin Rudd - Prime Minister of Australia. Supremely competent, both as a diplomat but also as a leader. However his popularity was destroyed by a campaign but Rupert Murdoch after he started to implement his campaign promise of a national fibre-to-the-home network. Ironically most people think it was his mining "super-tax" that turned the media against him but that was very much just a cover-up for the real reason Murdoch wanted him out.
Carter is different because the sentiment at the time was such there really wasn't a lot he could do. No ammount of competency was going to rescue the mess Nixon created. By decoupling the worlds currency system from gold and simultanously creating a situation where domestic oil production peaked the oil crisis was bound to happen eventually. The devaluation of the USD caused real loss in incomes from the middle-eastern countries and they (perhaps rightfully?) used this leverage to ratchet up prices and secure their own futures at the expense of global economic activity. They both fucked up though because the resulting oil glut really screwed the middle east in the following decade.
Either way, I don't buy the argument that Carter was incompetent because he didn't win a second term. I don't think anyone could have in those conditions and I also don't think he really had the power to change them. He did a decent job of implementing policies that would eventually shield the US from OPEC shenanigans but they took a long time to come to fruition, much too late to save his second term.
Well, it was all too much for most of the electorate. Carter did the hard things that needed to be done. Volcker raising interest rates was absolutely the right thing to do and it did quell inflation a few years down the road, but Carter bore the brunt of the immediate political fallout.
Carter was thinking further ahead than probably any president in my lifetime (from JFK through Biden). He was the first president to take climate change seriously. If we would've listened to him I think we wouldn't be in a lot of the messes we're in now. But American politics is a short-term game... and it's even moreso now than it was then.
Studies don't show that Americans vote much based on foreign policy, but they certainly crush the current president and Congress when the economy is bad and inflation is high. It doesn't matter whether he did anything to cause it or not.
Russia invading Ukraine seems to rhyme with the Soviet Union invading Afghanistan in 1980. Carter was not to blame for the latter and neither is Biden to blame for the former, but there was and will be political fallout.
Do you feel like there's current events comparison of Carter vs Biden?
>but they certainly crush the current president and Congress when the economy is bad and inflation is high.
Economy is doing pretty good, starting to kick in post-pandemic recovery boost. https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/gdp-growth-rate?co...
Yes inflation is out of control but economy is looking great right now.
>It doesn't matter whether he did anything to cause it or not.
I find that the case. When the economy is doing well, both sides claim success. Current president claims his actions and previous president claims older actions took some time to work out. When the economy isn't doing well, both sides claim not me. It was the other guy's fault.
American voters are very unforgiving to bad economies and bad foreign policy outcomes. Carter was the victim of both, and Reagan was a formidable candidate.
The hostage crisis probably broke him (the rescue attempt was a total disaster. Not his fault but it looked terrible) plus the inflation fighting Volker did. Reagan was also an excellent communicator. Hard to campaign against a guy like him.
Reagan was unquestionably anti-labor despite perversely being inducted into the Labor Hall of Fame by Trump's Labor Secretary.
Carter was the beginning of none of this.