The expression "[...] is win" is decidedly not win.
You may be trying to suggest that the grandparent post adds nothing to the discussion but that is not what you did. You criticised the grandparent for their association with an internet subculture's vernacular. Criticise the comment, not the parlance it is delivered in.
Maybe if we ridicule them enough they'll move on to more clever slang, or at least more obscure slang so that I no longer understand it enough for it to annoy me.
But I was pointing out something I found humorous in a joke checklist.
<--- ducks