[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_demand
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_demand
I rarely see economists invoke Econ 101 models such as [1],[2] except in extraordinarily constrained settings.
If you aren't invoking theorems about beta reduction for the simply typed lambda calculus to reason about C's memory model, then consider also refraining from using [1],[2] to analyze pretty much anything in a real economic system.
This isn't pedantic. This is a real difference in how engineers and software people treat laws in the natural sciences vs how laws get treated in economics by the same set.
You can call it a law, or a model, or whatever. The point -- and, not a pedantic one -- is that [1],[2] are almost never accurate enough to be useful and calling them laws doesn't change that fact.
Specifically, from what I've seen, behavioral economics precisely wishes to reject predicting behavior via these simple economic models in favor of more nuanced understandings of complex behaviors, derivable only through empirical observation of what consumers really do, not what they should do or a simplistic law predicts they should do.
(It's an interesting comparison to CS too.)
Particularly since the first behavioral economist to get a Nobel was also an early pioneer in many fields which are now housed in CS departments: programming languages, artificial intelligence, theorem proving.
Possibly referencing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_A._Simon
Thanks for your input in this thread!
They're always wrong.
Feel free to prove me wrong with a case history.
What constrains the supply of copies of a piece of software?
Nothing. Nearly all the software I use is free.
How about you being more specific?
Supply, demand, and price can all be manipulated, including in ways that divorce one from the other two. Either by governments or by sufficiently large private actors. This... isn't controversial, even among the most staunch of neo-classical economists.
> How about you being more specific?
Believe it or not, there exists non-free software. So, to be more specific, I am referring to literally any machine that is not running a completely FOSS stack. Or even any machine that IS running an entirely FOSS stack but is being used in commerce and where some parts of that software stack are patent-protected!
I.e., basically every machine used for commerce and the vast majority of consumer machines. 99% of the global install base? More?
Again, this whole thread is an excellent demonstration of my original post. This is the Econ equivalent of getting into an argument with a political scientist over whether NVIDIA's latest chip is really just a <insert idealized model of computation>. These arguments don't even happen, except in econ with non-economists, because nobody has strong ideological attachments to Newtonian mechanics or the number of tapes on a turing machine or whatever.
Rent control is an obvious example. Minimum wage laws, another. Anti-gouging laws, still another. All of them fail.
You appear to be arguing that S&D only applies to the marginal cost of reproduction. This is not the case.
Let's take an extreme example. You need some custom software for your business. You come to me. I'm going to charge you what it takes to develop the software plus a profit. Not the cost of reproduction of the software. Whether you and I agree on the price or not is a function of S&D.
And there's every point in between that and Linux.
BTW, I bet you're using a free browser to access HackerNews (I am - Chrome), and HN itself makes itself available for free.
As for copyright law, it is not setting prices any more than a law making it illegal to steal apples from my orchard is interfering with S&D.
> nobody has strong ideological attachments to Newtonian mechanics
S&D is not an ideology. It's the Law. Just like NM is the Law. It applies whether you believe it or not. You can't escape it. The communists tried really, really hard to deny the existence of S&D. They had about as much success as the flat earthers. Today's Progressivists are currently doing their best to deny S&D, with as little result as the communists.
And yes, I know NM is an approximation of Quantum Mechanics.
In physics, we are able to isolate systems to the point where this caveat is true and the law can be experimentally validated.
In economics, we do not get such affordances, because it is not and cannot be a "laboratory science".