I'm no expert myself, but my layman's understanding of some of the pushback behavioral economics has for the field of economics is relevant for your point.
Specifically, from what I've seen, behavioral economics precisely wishes to reject predicting behavior via these simple economic models in favor of more nuanced understandings of complex behaviors, derivable only through empirical observation of what consumers really do, not what they should do or a simplistic law predicts they should do.
(It's an interesting comparison to CS too.)