It's hard to say that Twitter breached their fiduciary duty when both their representing bank (Goldman) and the second largest shareholder (Kingdom Holding Company) both rejected the offer. The lawsuit will likely go nowhere; the sentiment is that the offer is way too low.
GS deserves some fire under them for this for sure. Not solely for rejecting it, but due to their stated reasoning for "why".
Their reasoning for rejecting the $54/share acquisition offer was "it is too low of a price target". In the meantime, Goldman's own last reported price target for Twitter is at $30/share.
Unless I misunderstand something about how such things work, which is entirely plausible, this isn't a good look for GS at all.
EDIT: as one of the replies pointed out, I was indeed misunderstanding the situation, and there is no actual discrepancy here. The entity saying "$54 is too low" was GS Bank, while "$30 is the target" statement was from GS Investments. They are separate entities and often disagree with each other.
It is the responsibility of the Bank to get maximum return on investment for the company. It is the responsibility of the Investments side to get as many customers in the door as possible and to provide them with timely information.
Ah, that actually makes perfect sense, thanks for clarifying.
Source? There is no such investor, at least not in the top 13: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FQWWgx_VsAUoFxT?format=jpg&name=...
> fiduciary duty
As mentioned here all the time. Fiduciary duty gives the board and company officers a very wide berth. Telling Musk his offer is too low, and enacting shareholder rights is just fine.
Its a 25% premium, quite typical for buyout offers.
Goldman could hold the position that the company's current performance justifies $30, but that $55 doesn't fairly reflect the longer-term potential in the business.
(It's also different sections of Goldman, with firewalls and different goals between them.)
It really depends how much he wants it, which only he knows.