No one is required to use GPL software. You're free to implement your clever idea in a way that doesn't make use of GPL software.
At that point, you're back to traditional copyright and other less restrictive schemes.
> He claims that it protects users, but this leaves out the people who spend the time and effort to develop that software product.
Some things really aren't all positives for everyone. The free software movement prioritises users first. Sometimes this is a negative for the developer's goals. But clearly by the existence of a large amount of free software, there are enough developer's sympathetic to this goal to make it work, and by eliminating those restrictions, I don't see how that's preferable (or even different) to the all rights reserved world.