I understand your point, but I am not convinced. Nit because I belive in some inherent superiority of some or another set of keybindings, but rather because on the one hand evil isn't a perfect emulation (any somewhat experienced Vim user can always name me a few faults), and on the other the very need for evil-collections to bridge the gap between Emacsy conventions that packages conventionally use and Vims keys (e.g. Dired becomes practically useless if it were to overwritten by Evil keys).