I'm unhappy about the weight SAT (and ACT) scores are given in the application process because I will be a (junior level) transfer student and I see even less relevance of the SAT in my position when it's already fairly useless for freshmen. I find it mindboggling and frustrating to think that half the colleges I am applying to are requiring such a useless thing while the others are doing the right thing by not even caring for such a score.
In college, I have taken math classes above second semester calculus. I have fulfilled basic general education requirements. I have fulfilled more than expected of a junior-level transfer student in classes related to my major. All of those credits should overwhelmingly trump what I can do in a few hours with a pencil and a calculator for something laughable in comparison. To the point that taking such a test would be unnecessary to point out what I am capable of doing: honestly, is how well I do on some trivial algebra (lazily done entirely with my ti-89) or writing going to tell you how appealing of a computer science major I will be? I'm pretty sure you can safely ignore the SAT and take a look at my classes, grades, experience and recommendations to make a better guess. And the same should apply to high school students as well.
Not to say I did not do well on the last SAT exam I took (on the contrary, because the material is so basic), but why I had to spend the money and waste the time to do so in the first place just stinks. I have taken prep classes way back in high school, and I've tutored people in turn. The article is spot on when it says that students are spending time gaming the SAT.
(On a slightly different sidenote, I don't think the SAT is the only cause for high school classes (at least in the US) being so focused on a small curricula, I believe that's more directly caused by NCLB and tying school performance on exams to funding. But that's a whole different rant/issue in itself.)