Truth be told, the SATs aren't particularly hard so most bright people could walk in and take the test cold turkey and pull at least a 1500. Of course, there were a lot of false positives from people who took prep courses and worked their asses off (but, as a former princeton review tutor, I never saw more than a 100 point gain in any student no matter how hard they worked - and most were lucky to get 50 points). A kid whose parents had a few grand to burn on a princeton review course could boost his score from 1300 to 1350, but never to 1550.
The problem with GPA/extracurriculars were that a lot of not very bright people could pull 4.0s and have good 'leadership' experience by gaming the system. And, even worse, a lot of smart people couldn't. A lot of the smartest people I know barely graduated highschool (or didn't). They saw the bullshit for what it was, and often had a knack for rubbing people the wrong way (especially at 16 - most of them can 'play the game' as adults).
(Note: all my experience was with the old 1600 point SAT)