Corporate ISPs sell whatever customer data they can get and meddle with traffic already, is there a way government can do worse than that? Not even Big Govt just municipal one...
The government has no profit motive to be siphoning your data as you browse (unlike a for-profit ISP), and the NSA isn't running local municipal broadband programs. (If they were, I guarantee you we'd see a lot more federal support for them.)
Asset seizure laws give them ample for-profit mechanisms, and you'd better believe that the municipal police department is going to ask the municipal ISP for a list of citizens connecting to TOR nodes for their no-knock probable-cause raids and seizure.
Why haven't we heard about this happening? And since when has it become commonplace for judges to hand out warrants for connecting to a TOR node?
They wouldn't need a warrant - that's the point.
Which would generally mean they have MORE rules about how they treat your data, all ISPs sell stuff directly to the government that would traditionally need a warrant for.
These are community run. If they were gleaning your bits, someone you run into would know about it and then you'd know, too.
I would trust muni broadband over Comcast any.day.of.the.week.