If we're going to try to re-engineer spoken English, I'd much rather address the root causes, which were the adoption of such literally black-and-white terms as racial identifiers in the first place. Calling light-skinned European-descended people "white" and dark-skinned members of the African diaspora "black" was always a divisive oversimplification of a nuanced web of ethnic heritages.
This doesn't fit neatly into a woke/anti-woke framework, but I try to avoid using "black" and "white" to describe people whenever I can, preferring something either more descriptive or contextual.
I am not advocating for banning the terms above, just to make an attempt going forward to slowly migrate to the other ones when possible.
Which is going to be very hard, because the reason for the association is from black being the unknown. It's the night that hides the predators. It's the shadow where the enemy hides. It's where you don't want to put your foot in case there are spiders or a sharp rock.
Humans are afraid of the dark. I've not even heard of being afraid of the light.
Death and darkness.
I'd like a historian to confirm, but I'd be very surprised if this type of language didn't exist in most places, including before ever seeing a darker skinned person.
But this effort is doomed to fail. You can be afraid of the dark at night and that is not a predictor at all of racism. Indeed, do people with darker skin not get afraid of the dark?
I agree that in some instances, white seems to be primarily used as a synonym for bright/light, and black as one for darkness, shadow etc., such as in the case of white and black box testing.
However, other cases, such as "whitelist" and "blacklist", seem more nefarious at least in some cultures: A list of names, one of people to grant access to some service or facility, the other to be denied...
And as somebody else has already noted, for somebody without that cultural background, it might not even make any sense, unlike the much more self-describing alternatives "allowlist" and "denylist".
If there is an alternative available that is both more straightforward and that has less negative connotations – why not advocate for its use, and assume that those that do so do it out of good intentions (while at the same time not assuming that people using the other terms do so out of a desire to cause harm)?
The main problem seems to be that, as in many such cases, a nuanced discussion of the topic does not fit into a tweet or news headline, nor a Slackbot autoresponse, and least of all into a grammar checker.
https://biblehub.com/john/3-19.htm
> The Light has come into the world, but men loved the darkness rather than the Light because their deeds were evil. Everyone who does evil hates the Light, and does not come into the Light for fear that his deeds will be exposed…
Another thing; even though this effort might be doomed to fail, do you think there are good reasons to attempt to change language in such a way?
In general, I tend to be against changing language, but I'm open to being convinced that a certain effort might be worthwhile.
I'm also somewhat pessimistic due to thinking that some other changes I've seen might be inevitable in the long run (seeing how these changes are being used by people my age, I hope it is just fashion - oh and I'm not talking here about changes to the English language).
I'm not categorically against it. I'm not in the right country to properly judge "master/slave". Those words have no association with people to me. But I don't care about "master/slave".
Though I can't find it now, I remember encountering cases where actually "blocklist" was a less descriptive term, even misleading.
I think it's great even though "crewed" is a terrible word, I can't think of a better one, and it's good to change away from "manned".
I'm perfectly willing to surrender the word "niggardly".
So it depends.
Banning words like "ninja", "dojo", "white glove treatment", "blind"... like... really?
What I think is doomed to fail is banning any language that involves color.
I'd say some words are in a "grey area", but I've seen people wanting to ban that term.
Mandating language like this is double plus ungood.
Focus on how real actions impact the people around you.
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/life/2013/02/25/language/the-ja...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction...
What's your objection to "allowlist" (or "golist") and "denylist"/"blocklist"/"stoplist"?
It's not often that we have an almost universally better alternative, but at least to me it seems like this is the case here. (Yes, allow/deny have one syllable more each, but I think we'll live.)
I don't like "allowlist" and "denylist" because they sound wrong to me: perhaps because the first element of a compound should be a noun, not a verb, but that's just an attempt to explain what I feel. I don't like "blocklist" because that sounds like a list of blocks, something in a file system. Of the ones you mention, I think I'd probably prefer "golist" and "stoplist", which I hadn't really considered before. They're also shorter than "allowlist" and "denylist".
According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the term "stop list" has been in use since 1920, but "go list" is not recorded.
>>His memory was stored with a black list of the enemies and rivals, who had traduced his merit, opposed his greatness, or insulted his misfortunes
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blacklisting#Origins_of_the_te...
Like what the actual fuck? I sincerely hope this was meant to be a reply to someone else, otherwise you need to drastically improve your reading comprehension.
The left eats its own rather than being patient or tolerant ("I shouldn't have to teach you!") to people who mean well, while the right allows people to fly way off the handle and still be within their tent because their tent expands to include increasingly extreme ideas.
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/05/social-...
We keep talking about social media and its problematic effects. Like we don't know how to be social or something anymore.
It's not social media. It's profit/engagement media. The social component is just the hook. The point of it all is basic profit feedback loops (which are far less greedy and evil than we make these utilities out to be--they're just doing what they were instituted to do).
My current brainstorm/crazy idea is that something like "non profit" regulations might be how we coral this nuttiness. It's been semi/mostly effective at corralling religion in America for many years. I'm not sure why we wouldn't benefit from moving the Twitter Day Saints and Instagramists and Tik-Tok-ies and SnapChat Witnesses and Roamin Pathic Twitch into the same "you have your place, you can take care of your own and collect enough funds to operate and some, but if you start looking too much like a business and/or play in politics too much, it's going to get really uncomfortable for you."