Elon Musk: 'the woke mind virus' is making Netflix unwatchable
businessinsider.com
businessinsider.com
I’m not a fan of the authoritarian, performative wokeness that he’s describing—similar to hard-right Christianity, I think that is indeed more about bullying than decency. But claiming that Netflix is “unwatchable” because of more black/gay people in shows—or, for that matter, pushing back on gratuitous nastiness—is ridiculous.
This is why a lot of us were very uneasy about someone like Musk being in charge of a communication medium as influential as Twitter. It wasn’t his stance on moderation; it’s that the guy is unstable and immature, and we didn’t trust him to act responsibly.
That's a pretty disingenuous summary. Being woke is about much more than that.
That Elon clutches his pearls at the horror of televised diversity is unsurprising, he is a yarpie.
On the other hand, Netflix actively intervenes in content and productions with DEI orientation, they'll hand backs scripts and 'require' this or that, and will also require production to meet all sorts of criteria, which may not have the effect we want.
I don't think anyone is cutting cables over this but I wonder if it'd be more appropriate for everyone to chill out on telling people how to tell stories and how to make them.
Maybe a better approach would be to just support good content creation in different areas without resorting to intervention - and - ignoring the obviously political kind of thing.
Before 2000, particularly in the 1970's there were tons of bands with Black and White members. Tons. You just don't see that anymore. Can you think of any kind of 'groups' that have black and white dudes? It was inherently a political statement back then to be that way - but it was not overtly progressive. They were just making music! And though they were difficult times racially, mostly they were not singing about that. They sang about good times, peace, getting laid etc..
In effect the 'DEI' stuff happened, but in an organic manner, secondary to the direct orientation of 'making music'.
There will always be a few 'Archie Bunker' shows to get us to think about the 'hard issues' but by and large, I think we can actually make progress without trying so hard.
(I know that neither of those examples happened at Netflix. But both happened fairly recently in the Anglosphere, which is probably the wokest pole of the Western world.)
No one in their sane mind would portray, say, Martin Luther King as a blond Swede, or a historical Japanese Shogun as a Maori.
That is why such a view is seen as racist, or at the very least a double standard against black people.
There's actually iconography in Minoan Crete showing African Black folks (from Northern Africa of course, but Black folks were never exclusive to "Sub-Saharan" Africa anyway) as very well socially integrated, in the same social roles as "white" (actually, Levantine/Mediterranean) characters. So that's probably a bad example seeing as Minoan Crete itself may be the origin of the Achilles myth.
And yes, they could be very effective warriors too, not unlike Achilles himself. In a radically un-Woke twist, a later source (Frontinus' Stratagems) goes as far as to describe a group of auxilia troops (i.e. quasi-mercenaries) from Africa fighting valiantly for the Carthaginians as nigerrimī.
Disagreeing with the woke movement doesn't mean one is a supporter of discrimination.
And I especially don't think having a disabled black gay protagonist in a new series is going to help minorities find jobs or education. They are all about making it look like they care.
> And I especially don't think having a disabled black gay protagonist in a new series is going to help minorities find jobs or education. They are all about making it look like they care.
I am not sure it is your decision whether somebody else cares. I don't think having a show for teenage girls with ponies changes anything in the world for better, but for some girl in some dire situation it might just be the fantasy she needs. You know, like the million male power fantasies of saving the world while getting all the women to love you — which also doesn't help us.
If you criticize a media product for not helping which is targeted at one group of people, why stop there and not get rid of all media products that are not helping any kind of people?
Or is it (understandably) something else when it is about media representation oneself can identify with?
Nitpicking, and you say "rarely" so you might know this, but indeed that's not completely true. Italians were marginalized in Switzerland in the 50s and 60s, up to the early 70s.
Even recently a right-wing party was depicting Italians as rats that eat/steal Swiss cheese: https://www.repstatic.it/content/localirep/img/rep-milano/20...
I had a sentence in the post about the guest workers invited to Germany during these times in there, but decided to remove it for brevity and for a focus onto today.
I grew up in a massive right wing area in Austria, so I based my judgment on the xenophobic sentiment I was hearing during that time.
We as a humanity don't tell ourselves stories because the stories solve problems — we tell ourselves stories for a heap of other reasons.
One such reason would be escapism: The creation of worlds in which people can fantasize themselves, because there is some character who is the way they secretly see themselves. This is why we have films with cool guys who fare well in critical situations while getting all the women. This is why we have horse themed films for teenage girls.
I don't like horse themed films for teenage girls, but as a grown man I don't see why such things shouldn't exist.
Same for films where the stories are based on the fantasies of other people who are not like me. Who am I to decide what other people should like?