>I cannot tell who made what TV when I look at them at Walmart from 10 feet away.

That made me laugh and it's definitely true but a TV is just a box that shows a picture. With computer it is different because there are so many paths one can choose to create an individual UX.

>So they did identify it.

True but the neither the judge or lead council really knew which goes to the point of the average user being confused. I could, as you and others, spot the difference.

I'm not a lawyer, so I won't pretend to understand patent law, but I will say that I'm disappointed by other tablet UI designs with the lone exception being the Metro UI. There is a great chance to explore instead of playing it safe. To me it is offensive since you are literally being given a blank slate with which to create.