I think there are plenty factors at play here. Spring resistance, wobbliness of the switch, activation distance, feel of the tactile bump/click…
Recently I've been using Otemu brown, violet, and orange and Gateron browns. All should be quite similar, yet in the end they feel totally diferent. I love Otemu oranges and dislike brown and violet. Gateron browns feel very good, but a bit wobbly for my taste.
I have tested more than 20 switch types, and most of my guesses based on someone else opinion or specification were usually wrong. The only thing I know is that I want tactile switches, with rather low activation force. Except of that, I have no idea if I'll like the switch or not.
I like the way that author approaches this, but I'm not sure we can conclude anything from a scientific approach here. Switches are just like art or music. Sometimes you like a song you think you should hate. Yet it makes something to you and you just can't stop listening ;)