Hacker News Reader

Comment by presentation | Hacker News Reader

This lacks part of what makes Twitter and Reddit usable - the context of a conversation is clear. Here, you just see the latest comments on a thread, but you have to scroll way up to see the conversation up to that point.

In Reddit everything is threaded. In Twitter you respond to specific Tweets. Here, you just have an unorganized list of every comment. So as a casual, I don't feel compelled to participate in conversations that have already started, which is most of them, so I lose interest in engaging with this.

View on HN

That's good feedback and thanks for sharing.

The primary driver in building this was first to create a way to easily hop into a live conversation around a topic with anyone.

This has been a bootstrapped one-person project so far and it also comes down to how much I can handle building at a time, and what to prioritize to walk the fine line from 0 -> 1.

I def agree and plan to add ways to add context to conversations and make it easier to navigate through the history of ones already in progress.

Like I wrote in https://sqwok.im/p/RkettQRCNX82xA (would love if the timestamp for a specific post in a thread was a permalink):

Threaded conversations and upvote buttons!

Chats work well with family and friends, but with this many users interacting I feel it's very difficult to follow a conversation. I just end up scrolling up and down trying to get some context.

Hey thank you for sharing this feedback and linking to it here on HN! It will make it easier for me to find again. I agree the ability to break off the convo is a big one, and likewise permalink/vote or highlight message.

Thank you!

My pleasure! I'm mostly in the fediverse these days, but it looks like you're on to something.

> thank you for sharing this feedback and linking to it here on HN! It will make it easier for me to find again.

I think this reply further highlights the need for permalinks and threads. :)

totally! thanks again! :)

I feel the same way. Not to say this is a bad idea, chat / IRC / etc. are all massively successful and when I was younger I loved hanging out on chat.

The problem for me is chat is synchronous. You have to sit there staring at it to participate in conversations. As a result, since I now have kids/job/etc. I basically can't participate in communities which are primarily chat based (like Discord, IRC, and so on).

The only communities I still participate in actively are those on reddit, precisely because I can engage at my leisure rather than having to respond in near real time. I feel it's the closest we have to mailing lists and forums of old.

I def understand that and I'm interested in finding ways to support more nuanced discussion, but there's always going to be a place for traditional threaded comments and old school forums etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com