I think you will find it hard to separate the concept of a macrostate from the state of knowledge (or ignorance) of an individual subjective observer.
I think you will find it hard to separate the concept of a macrostate from the state of knowledge (or ignorance) of an individual subjective observer.
Say I flip 8 coins and I don't look at the results. A fine-grained macro state is TTTT TTTT. A coarser-grained macro state is TTTT xxxx. The one has 4 bits more entropy than the other. It works the same way in statistical mechanics. Call them spins.
We're just talking about some ensemble of micro states, and then we divide the ensemble up into macro-states. To do statistical mechanics at all, I think I have to define some macro-states according to which micro-states they contain. That doesn't mean I necessarily have any information about which macro-state the system is actually in.
Talking bout the entropy of the macrostate TTTTxxxx makes sense only conditional on the TTTT information.
If we just define the macro-states, we're good to go. We don't need to talk about 'knowledge'. We can talk about 'knowledge', it's fine, but that lets in unnecessary woo.
The entropy of a macrostate is a measure of the indetermination about the microstate conditional on the macrostate. If you don't want to call that 'knowledge' the substance of the matter doesn't change.
A macrostate is not an intrinsict property of a physical system. It's related to our description of the system. In general, the same microstate of the system of interest may be compatible with multiple macrostates.
Given the thermodynamical description of some system I can calculate the entropy if T=T_1 and the entropy if T=T_2 without knowing what's the actual temperature specifying the macrostate. But in the first case the calculation is conditional on the hypothetical information T=T_1 and in the second case conditional on T=T_2.
Adding "knowlege" to the definition (or to an initial explanation) of entropy makes that learning process even more difficult. And it's unnecessary. It's better than the older talk about "disorder" but it's distracting. We can bypass 'knowledge' and come back later, with no penalty and plenty of time savings.
Apart from that single pedagogical point, we seem to be saying the same things back and forth to each other in different words. I'm not sure why.
The concept of how much can we tell about the microstate given only the pressure and temperature seems quite natural and a better starting point. Boltzmann's entropy is a nice illustration but there is no reason to avoid the general concept.
If given the macrostate all microstates are equally probable we can just count them. The more there are the higher the entropy.
In general we have a probability distribution for microstates conditional on the macrostate. To have a clear understanding of entropy that should be at least mentioned.
But nobody does that since the total value of entropy isn't important. What you do is count the factor difference in count of microstates between two volumes, that is what you care about, and it is easy to see how the number of microstates changes when you double the volume or other similar changes.
How would you say that it changes then?
I'd say that the number of compatible microstates doesn't change. The probability of each microstate does change though.
How do you calculate the number of microstates for the sample of gas before and after? How do you think these numbers are related? You said it was easy!
> How do you calculate the number of microstates for the sample of gas before and after? How do you think these numbers are related?
If you added energy to the gas by heating it, lets say you doubled the energy, then you now have twice as many energy packets to distribute between the particles. This adds a lot more microstates that wasn't available before, and none of the old microstates are now possible since all old microstates had a total energy level half of what each new microstate has. You can calculate the change in states yourself, it is just discrete normal probability theory. Note that the base rate isn't interesting, you care about the change of the logarithm of number of states.
As I'm sure you know, the microstates of that sample of gas at some fixed temperature don't have all the same energy. For each temperature there will be a distribution of possible energies. If the temperatures are close enough there will be a large overlap between those distributions.
You cannot just count the microstates of the sample of gas. (You can count microstates of the gas plus reservoir system though.)
Depends if you do classical statistical physics or quantum. If you do classical they all have the same energy. If you do quantum you have to weight the states according to their probability densities, and the probabilities that the energy deviates are very small which is why classical works fine even when ignoring those.
But quantum statistical physics is way more complex, you should learn the classical statistical physics first before you try to discuss quantum statistical physics. Classical works a lot like the computer science version where you just count states, quantum doesn't.
That's just completely wrong. With all due respect, you should (re?)learn the classical statistical physics :-)
So for example, if you have a gas as a closed system, takes a part of that, then you can measure that parts energy distribution by just accumulating the different micro states, yes. But if you view that part as a closed system, then if it has higher energy then it has higher temperature (if it is in the same phase) and thus energy will on average flow out of it to the other parts, if it didn't have higher temperature then it would be a stable system and that part would just have higher energy, which we know doesn't happen in for example gasses, (but it can happen with phase transitions, like an ice cube in water).
Edit: And it doesn't make sense to talk about temperature of subsets of systems. Temperature only deals with what happens when you connect two large systems, it is a macroscopic property, so when you calculate temperature you always deal with calculate that via entropy of closed systems.
So Boltzmann distribution happens when you have calculated the temperature for a macroscopic system as if it was closed, and then you start to calculate properties of some subsystem of that, that is how you get Boltzmann distribution. Not sure how you think these things were derived, have you tried reading a physics book on the subject and gone through how the formulas are derived?
Also, in these calculations you never ever mix two temperatures in a single system, as that isn't stable. The formulas only works for stable states. So if you have two different temperatures you have two different systems.
Edit Edit: I can't post more since I sometimes post stupid political stuff. Anyway, I answered your post already, the formulas we are talking about here doesn't deal with the case where systems of different temperatures interact. They only work for closed systems. If you heat a subset of a room to a higher temperature, then you now have a dynamic system where energy flows out of that subset, none of the formulas we have discussed here applies in that scenario. You can use them to calculate approximate properties of the systems by treating them as if they were closed though, still the Boltzmann distribution doesn't apply there for the entirety of those subsystems, since it assumes that everything surrounding it has the same temperature, which in your scenario the surroundings do not.
Anyway, all of these formulas are derived based on completely closed systems with no transfer of energy or particles. that is the source of entropy calculations, if you want to understand entropy you have to deal with such systems. Boltzmann's law is an example of a formula derived from entropy calculations, you can't use that to talk about entropy.
(Note, I learned these things in another language than English, so I might use the wrong words for some things, but I know how statistical physics, temperature and entropy works, are derived etc)
Wrong again!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closed_system
"In thermodynamics, a closed system can exchange energy (as heat or work) but not matter, with its surroundings."
Maybe you meant "isolated" instead of "closed" - but then I don't know what we have been talking about. (When I say "we" I mean "you".)
> It doesn't make sense to count the microstates for a volume of gas at some pressure and temperature.
A volume of gas at some pressure and temperature is a closed system but not an isolated system.
> I can have a container with 1l of some gas at room temperature T1 and proceed to heat the room - and the container - to temperature T2.
The containers in that example are closed systems but not isolated systems.
> the microstates of that sample of gas at some fixed temperature don't have all the same energy
That sample of gas at some fixed temperature is a closed system but not an isolated system.
Hopefully you'll agree with everything I wrote with the understanding that we were not talking about isolated systems.
[ have _you_ tried reading a physics book? :-) ]
I thought we were discussing statistical mechanics.
This is from the message that you first replied to in this thread:
"Typically when you calculate the entropy of a system at temperature X, that means all you know is that you stuck a thermometer in it and measured X. You don't know anything more than the average temperature. It could be in any state consistent with that temperature."
Will you tell students to count the microstates consistent with the temperature?
This macrostate seems fine enough to be a microstate, but sure. For the macrostates with at least one 'x' in it, that 'x' seems to be a placeholder for the concept of subjective ignorance.
> That doesn't mean I necessarily have any information about which macro-state the system is actually in.
But the entire purpose of the exercise of assigning microstates to macrostates is so that you can match up a description of some system to a microstate ensemble and calculate its entropy! Otherwise there's no point to arbitrarily labelling various groups of microstates.
To follow your example more practically, let's say you have an 8-spin system, whose net spin is zero. (You know because you've measured its overall magnetic moment or something). I've just described a system that is in one of the following possible microstates:
TTTT HHHH, TTTH HHHT, ..., HHHH TTTT
Now you can go ahead and define the macrostates as fine-grained as you want, where TTTT HHHH and HHHH TTTT are in different macrostates, but to calculate the entropy of this system, you're going to have to sum up all of those macrostates anyway to get the one that's consistent with the described system.
What I'm saying is pedagogical. We need to define our macro-states. We don't need to go on and talk about our definitions being information or 'knowledge.' We could just use the definitions and calculate. We can talk about 'knowledge' but we don't need to.
The exception is when we actually have some information about what macro-state some system is really in. Obviously we then have to build that information into our model, and the entropy changes. What I'm saying is this: it's not necessary to mix that into our definition of entropy. That definition is not going to help folks who don't understand entropy, and it's unnecessary.