That gets us a world without patent trolls, and without interval wipers (and everything else invented by an individual inventor who wasn't in a position to start a company to implement the idea). Is that a strictly better world?
“I try to license the patent to auto companies”
Many patent trolls never even attempt licensing, they just wait to sue or settle. This would not remove all trolls but would be a first step.
Maybe patents should indeed only be enforceable by those that produce the invention (practicing entities as it was called above, not sure if that's an official term or something they came up with) and if you want royalties then you should put that in the contract when you sell the patent rather than sitting on patents without doing anything useful. That way we can have individual inventors (they are rewarded by what they make from the patent's sale) without also allowing trolls to claim to be inventors (because "NPEs" can't actually sue for infringement).
Or perhaps this should be a software thing, I don't know enough about how well this stuff worked for other fields honestly. I've only ever heard bad stories but then I also hang out with open source communities.
Edit: I realized one might think this makes the patent useless. If you can't sue for infringement as entity that doesn't produce the invention itself, any company could produce it and ignore you. Correct. However, I'm sure that if EvilCorp ignores your patent sale offer and produces GreatInvention without a license, MegaCompetitor would love to take the GreatInvention patent off your hands and license it to EvilCorp (or not and just block further use by EvilCorp). Thus the inventor can still be rewarded for the sale (incentivizing inventions), the new owner gets benefits of exclusivity for the parent's remaining duration, and it forces the invention to be available on the market (it can't only be locked away uselessly).
There's something to say for gjsman-1000's idea, or shall we say, invention
You are now advocating for only MegaCorps to own patents. Pretty wild to see HN users say that startups should not be allowed to compete with incumbents.
> Pretty wild to see HN users say that startups should not be allowed to compete with incumbents.
Pretty wild to be so misinterpreted. Of course startups should be able to use a patent. The point is just that an entity that does not make use of it also does not get to make use of the exclusivity granted.
A "startup" that only exists to enforce patents would be the definition of a patent troll afaik, hence me liking the idea that one needs to use the patent to make use of its rights. (Edit, Wikipedia: "Patent trolls often do not manufacture products or supply services based upon the patents in question.")
> how could MegaCompetitor block further use without a lawsuit (which could result in an injunction)?
Who said anything about "without a lawsuit"? See the part where I said that patents should perhaps only:
>> be enforceable by those that produce the invention
So when MegaCompetitor makes wipers from the example above, they can enforce that EvilCorp doesn't make wipers during the patent's validity period. Since the government has a monopoly on force, that means they need a lawsuit with an injunction as goal. (I'm not a lawyer though, nor natively English, hope I'm understanding and using the word injunction correctly.)
This is even better because things can't just be patented and that knowledge locked away without anybody able to use it.