Except in cases of men who are raped, it absolutely represents a choice on the part of the man. The fact that you can't force a woman to have an abortion (or to not have one) after the fact doesn't seem like an infringement on your rights.
Except in cases of men who are raped, it absolutely represents a choice on the part of the man. The fact that you can't force a woman to have an abortion (or to not have one) after the fact doesn't seem like an infringement on your rights.
It definitely makes some men anxious, and every time it’s mentioned, floods of people come in to trivialize these concerns while also saying men need to step up. Gets boring.
Let's say a man wants a baby and the woman doesn't. It seems the woman has control over: consent to unprotected sex, hormonal birth control, and abortion. The man has control over consent to unprotected sex.
Now, let's say a man doesn't want a baby. The woman has control over: consent to protected/unprotected sex, hormonal birth control (including Plan B), abortion, and whether to give up the child (some states allow for surrender which absolve child support obligations). The man has control to consent to protected sex only (all the mitigations like birth control can be lies and there's no way to legally enforce them like you could stealthing in CA).
As you see, the power dynamics are skewed heavily.
Equating these things with condoms is pretty lame. Condoms are cheap, sold everywhere, are more effective than the other methods, and can be used with zero advance planning or side effects.
"can be used with zero advance planning or side effects."
You have to at least plan to have one, which can be more difficult if you or the partner have a latex allergy.
Find another woman ?
> The man has control over consent to unprotected sex.
Choice
>Now, let's say a man doesn't want a baby. >The man has control to consent to protected sex only
Choice again
> As you see, the power dynamics are skewed heavily.
But the outcomes are skewed heavily too
In a tiny percentage of cases intercourse produces a baby
The woman has to carry the baby to term for 9 months, take care of her body, eat well, rest enough, don’t drink alcohol, stop working, go through a painful delivery that will change her body forever, doctors are involved, life or death situations then the baby needs food and clothing…
Men often take what they can get, because a significant number have well-founded fears that they might not have another chance.
Then don’t
I was referring to the scenario of man wants baby, woman does not
What are you going to do at that point ?
Yes, unprotected sex has a relatively small fertilization rate. That is also true for the life and death situations you mention (unprotected sex could also be life or death depending on communicable diseases if we are looking at edge cases).
"then the baby needs food and clothing…"
Which doesn't only affect the mother. Child support is a larger burden on the non-custodial parent, which tends to be men. That lasts a lot longer than 9 months too. I know people who had to pick up second jobs, be subjected to more stress, etc to make those payments and it affected their health. So the costs may come in different forms, but they do affect both parents.
"that will change her body forever"
What are the scope, occurrence, and significance of those? In my very limited experience, I don't notice any significant, permanent, negative changes in the majority of cases.
The easiest way to demonstrate this skewed power dynamic is to understand that baby trapping only works for one sex, as they are the only ones with the post intercourse mitigations.
I'm not saying anything is necessarily wrong. What am I saying is that concerns about a lack of control over a life changing event are not trivial for either parent, and one of them is completely under the control of the other in the event their limited choice (condom) fails.
Ejaculations (can) have consequences
The only thing that makes it non-trivial for males is child support - and that is a recent invention
Social pressure and stigma on unwed mothers has been orders of magnitude stronger than for fathers
That’s where shotgun weddings come from, to preserve honor and enforce social norms, making sure two parents take care of the kid
Birth control for men is still quite limited. There is not a single non-permanent method that has a effectiveness of over 90% per year per couple. The closest to that is the condom:
https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/condom
Giving men equal rights in the decision to become a parent would mean giving them the right to legal parental surrender.
That’s the point people seem to overlook.
There is no particularly good reason why all men should not be able to surrender parental rights especially early on say during the first trimester and essentially be treated as sperm donors as far as the law goes (tho from my understanding in some or even many jurisdictions sperm donors aren’t protected from that either beyond their anonymity).
At that point the woman still has a choice if she wishes to continue with the pregnancy on her own or terminate it.
Basically it would turn the equation from do you want to have a child to do you want to have a child without any financial support from the father.
Common bait&switch argument.
It’s not a choice as far as women are concerned (so women deserve another choice in the form of abortion) but it’s a choice for men?
You can’t have it both ways and claim to not be sexist.
What if we agree it's ultimately the choice of whoever has a baby growing inside them regardless of their sex?
Edit: but in general I care more about equality than about a particular solution. Either both men and women have a choice after sex, or neither. The current sexist solution is the worst.
https://philip.greenspun.com/blog/2016/12/12/failed-abortion...
Ozer reportedly offered her tens of thousands of dollars to terminate her pregnancy, amid other messages, calling her “white trash” and telling her “I f***ing hate you.” ... He reportedly made the cash payment offer through a colleague. The Post reports that the colleague told Naymark, “He’d be willing to offer a lump sum of money to you . . . I’m sure he would have no problem with 50k-75,000+.”
That's a "negotiated market rate"? From your link: The friend’s purported offer of “50k-75,000+” is not consistent with attorney-handled transactions
What point exactly are you trying to make here?