Dating apps are a way to gain insight into psychology. If you don't use dating apps, the preferences remain.
There's a lot to say about how the structure and dynamics. of a tool guide how we use it, and that's very much at play here.
These same people acted FAR different in the outside world. I think the notion of a complete lack of scarcity leads our brains in this unachievable quest for perfection (based on nothing but a picture).
I'd say get off the platform, but you also have to go where the people are! I'm just glad I'm not dating anymore.
My additional accecdata: it's really, really not. Even for an individual, stated preferences are often not that true in practice.