So, he sat at every light with the brake pushed hard to the floor, trying to keep it from plunging into the intersection. As a long-time stick shift driver, I asked him why he didn't just shift it into neutral.
What if the engine free-revs and redlines on neutral?
Maybe turning it off might be a safer alternative.
But almost any engine with electronic ignition (so early 80s or later for a standard car or motorcycle, with plenty earlier having that feature) will cut spark to control RPM as needed. Unless you just start getting ignition breakup at RPM (not enough dwell time for the coil).
For throttle stuck fully open, going very fast on the highway, yeah you're gonna redline, but it's probably better to redline in neutral while you pull over than to turn the key off while you're still driving.
Not to drop old man wisdom here but back in the day power brakes were an option that you could pay for.
The next day my friends e90 BMW m3 power steering boiled over. And another friends F80 M4 had multiple power steering failures. They weren’t exactly happy about it either.
For example pre 1900:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hit-and-miss_engine
Later:
https://www.jalopyjournal.com/forum/threads/mechanical-rev-l...
1970s electronic type:
https://www.428cobrajet.org/id-governor
Even my push mower has a rev limiter, it just gets called a governor on that engine.
The majority of large American engines used the valves as the rev limiter. The valve springs were so weak that past a certain RPM the performance of the engine falls off so fast it isn't going to rev anymore, even in neutral. The valves never fully close, so performance is very poor. This is well below the mechanical limitations of the crankshaft, so nothing is really going to happen. Once interference engines showed up as common place in the market, it became mandatory to have a rev limiter. This happened as electronic ignition and fuel injection became more common, so it was logically incorporated into the ECU as time went on.
> I would take a blown engine over flying into an intersection any day of the week.
And this is why we need to build experience. Young drivers very often are confronted with decisions like this but their mind phrases it as "Blown engine that I do not have to funds to pay for in Dad's car, or just hold this pedal firmly and everything will be all right".Unfortunately, the problem with experience is that the lesson comes only after the test.
Which one are you optimizing for?
> Maybe turning it off might be a safer alternative.
Young drivers might not understand the difference between the powered-down and the pull-the-key-out positions. There is a real danger of locking the steering wheel in this case.The statute of limitations has passed on all of my “she’ll be a’ight” endeavors, but they included having to manually apply throttle to keep the engine lit, driving on partial service brakes, driving without a working charging system, having to push start the car, reckoning speed by gear and RPM, and fueling based on ded reckoning with an INOP fuel gauge and odometer.
Obviously if you want to drive like a jerk you need the car to be in tip top shape so that you have the most freedom to make control inputs but if you just want to putt along and drive in a mild mannered way having a bunch of mechanical oddities that constrain what you can do isn't a big deal.
Likely he just had a high idle due go some vacuum leak or whatever, as you said.
However if the throttle is stuck and you are in neutral you'll end up revving at redline until you turn off the engine. Not the end of the world momentarily but you don't want to leave the engine revving that high for a prolonged period of time.