That's good. It would be even better to show that they are GPL non-compliant by showing their response and confirming they're not willing to comply. As you said, you're not able to, and that's fine, I'm just saying it would be even better if you could.
> I do have the time, energy, resources and motivation to share this singular fact with others so they can make their own choice about which companies they support.
That's fine.
I agree with you that Onyx is likely in violation of the GPL. That said, the way I'm used to things is; the person who alleges a crime is committed is the one that has to show evidence. Onyx doesn't have to prove they're innocent. The prosecution has to prove they're guilty.
So if we want to see Onyx punished, then we need to find someone who owns an Onyx that has asked Onyx to comply with the GPL and provide source, and showing that they refused to do so. At that point, they would immediately be non-compliant and thus susceptible to many injunctions, meaning their products could be stopped at the border. Pretty sure they'd pay attention to that.
http://bbs.onyx-international.com/t/install-linux-or-alterna...
I see the link shows a forum discussion. I guess I was looking for something more like:
So if we want to see Onyx punished, then we need to find someone who owns an Onyx that has asked Onyx to comply with the GPL and provide source, and showing that they refused to do so. At that point, they would immediately be non-compliant and thus susceptible to many injunctions, meaning their products could be stopped at the border. Pretty sure they'd pay attention to that.
It needs to be a clear formal request with proof of ownership and failure of the supplier to provide source for the GPL to be applicable.
That's in the link I provided.
Unfortunately, there isn't an automatic enforcement mechanism for cross-border GPL violations. There aren't lawyers waiting in the wings to file lawsuits on behalf of hackers who want to own their device. There isn't a framework for reporting these violations to any higher authority to advocate for us. I wish it were the case, but it's not.
There is gpl-violations.org. Has anyone tried them?
Here's one response from the company where they deflect on this issue: https://i.redd.it/0lx58maqrbb51.png
The link you were shared above on Wikipedia also has another response, where they decline to provide source: http://bbs.onyx-international.com/t/install-linux-or-alterna...
Looking at that picture, I see a comment on a forum from "Onyx-Boox.ru". Is that the same as Onyx, the company that actually ships the products worldwide? My suggestion to you guys is:
So if we want to see Onyx punished, then we need to find someone who owns an Onyx that has asked Onyx to comply with the GPL and provide source, and showing that they refused to do so. At that point, they would immediately be non-compliant and thus susceptible to many injunctions, meaning their products could be stopped at the border. Pretty sure they'd pay attention to that.
It needs to be a clear formal request with proof of ownership and failure of the supplier to provide source for the GPL to be applicable.
https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/hl09g7/onyx_boox_chi...
https://www.reddit.com/r/Onyx_Boox/comments/hsn7kx/onyx_usin...