Is there any non-horror piece of code where supporting this latter case would be useful?
a = 1
def foo():
x = a
a = 2
foo()
> UnboundLocalError: local variable 'a' referenced before assignment
Basically a name cannot be both global and local inside the same function. Otherwise it would be a total mess."a = a" just means assign the value of local variable "a" to a local variable "a", so the error makes sense.