Yeah, Odyssey was a great success. Great sales. Great consumer and critic reviews.
I suspect it just got overshadowed by Zelda Breath of the Wild, which really stole the show for the Switch launch year.
Edit: Trying to think which Mario game was NOT considered a success? Maybe Mario Sunshine? That goes back to the Gamecube, and looking at it now... that ALSO had good reviews. I don't think there's been a dud in the mainline Mario franchise... ever?