> The mistake these courts are making is thinking that the punishment is meant for the individual committing the crime ONLY. In fact, it is a deterrent for OTHERS to think twice before attempting a crime.
That's not a mistake they are making, because:
(1) No one was convicted of a crime, so there are no “criminals” involved, and
(2) It doesn't make deprivation of rights without legal basis acceptable that it is done to deter people other than those being immediately deprived of rights.
> Rulings like this will have a very predictable outcome
Yes, and that outcome is “law enforcement will need to charge people with crimes and prove them to the criminal standard of ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ before depriving them of liberty on the basis that they are criminals.”