The standard cop out is to say that line even when it’s completely unnecessary. It’s just easier to add it than consider how your words may be missunderstood.
The standard cop out is to say that line even when it’s completely unnecessary. It’s just easier to add it than consider how your words may be missunderstood.
If you wore an I’m with her! tee, you would not claim to have a neutral opinion on politics.
Someone literally explained to you that it's a matter of transparency, and you're jumping to, "well obviously they're just bootlickers".
If you work for Google, comment in public on Google stuff, with an account that says “I work for Google!”, I would say it is not possible for you to remain independent, no matter what kind of spell-of-disclaiming is attached to your post.
When it comes to Google matters, one either comments as a Google employee, or not at all. It comes across as distasteful to try to do wade in while waving off claims of bias with “opinions are my own” with the implication that they are unbiased.
Maybe what these people mean is: I work at Google so this is biased towards them, but they didn’t tell me to write this, and perhaps I should be reading it that way?
Good thing nobody said this, then. They're just making it clear that they're not explicitly relaying company opinion.
> with the implication that they are unbiased.
Nobody's trying to imply this. Obviously if you work at company X, you're gonna have at least some subconscious bias. The point is to make your potential bias transparent, so others can judge for themselves.
> I work at Google so this is biased towards them, but they didn’t tell me to write this
Yes, though of course the amount of bias can vary. I used to work at Amazon, and my opinion of Amazon didn't seem to significantly change when I started working there, or when I left.
(Of course some people develop a more negative opinion of a company after working there, rather than a positive one)
I'd say that a situation where you feel the need to add that sort of disclaimer generally means you should keep your mouth shut, but stopping people from talking about things they know about will never happen.
In other industries, you'll find similar boilerplate disclaimers like "this is not investment advice." Particularly amusing when it is attached to even character-limited tweets.
To borrow your broken analogy and fix it, if someone were to post "Hey, here are all the reasons I'm voting for (candidate) and I think you should too", and didn't disclose that they work for that candidate's campaign, don't you think any credibility they might have had is gone once it's found out?
What I’m getting at is that opining, disclosing, but then claiming the opinions are unbiased just does not compute.
If it's positive, then leaving off the disclaimer is basically astroturfing.
If you're wearing an I'm with her! tee, you also aren't her spokesperson.
It's not neutrality, it's non-representative
The point of the "I work at X" disclaimer is to explicitly point out that you do have a conflict of interest that the reader needs to be aware of.
Disclaimer: I work at Google and my thoughts are my own. ;)
Disclaimer: All my opinions are Google's ;)
Why do people think it? If they see me say "I work at Google" in the comment, and then say some sort of opinion or recommendation or prediction, they might think that that's an opinion that's widely held or officially promoted within Google, or that the recommendation is something that Google recommends or that the prediction is something Google predicts. The sentence "I work at Google" could be thought of as something I'm invoking to say "I'm an authority believe me", or "I work at Google, so I can provide you info from Google", rather than a disclaimer about a conflict of interest. That's why "I work at Google" is often followed by "but my thoughts are my own".
The phrase "identify as" refers to considering that a nontrivial part of one's identity.
These are separate concepts that happen to use similar wording.