It'd be more useful if it worked with any messaging app that was running on my phone though!
Vendors should include only the bare essentials, then let users who want more add their own extras.
Imagine an OS similar to the original Macintosh, or maybe early versions of iOS, but with add-ons that can add features to the global UI. New users have a basic system with easily-understood behaviors, and experienced users can enable the features they need.
In an alternate universe where I believed it was possible to compete with the major vendors, this is the platform I would build...
iPhones have a feature where you can create PDFs page by page, using the camera as a scanner. After you snap the photo it offers you a crop and transform tool, and does a little image recognition to assist you and make the edges of the crop tool snap to the page within the photo.
I've found that feature immensely useful in a professional context and (it was a company device) when I gave the phone back I seriously considered switching away from Android for my personal phone.
Little things like that, baked into the OS, make for a really awesome UX.
The files app should be exclusively for listing/moving/copying files. Files themselves should be created by and opened with different apps.
This isn't to say apps shouldn't be able to talk to the files app. On macOS, for example, apps can install QuickLook plugins.
It's been a few years since I had that phone so the details are a bit fuzzy but I seem to recall it was very discoverable from the email attachment interface, at the very least.
Problem with a separate app is that it's a separate codebase and thus easier for it to fall to neglect.
That's great if I'm sending an email, but what if I want to upload the documents to a website, or send them via iMessage, or Airdrop them to another Apple device, or print out the scan to effectively make a second paper copy? Do you add the icon to each of these interfaces, taking up screen real estate and adding mental load? (One new icon is never a problem, but do it 30 times and you'll be in a bad spot.)
IMO, Apple's strategy significantly railroads users, while making interfaces ever-more complicated.
> Problem with a separate app is that it's a separate codebase and thus easier for it to fall to neglect.
Yeah, bundling everything into iTunes worked really well for Apple, didn't it? :D
I really don't think we should be making UI decisions based on this.
I'm not really an "Apple Guy" so it's not clear to me what you are referring to.
When Apple finally killed the Mac version of iTunes on stage at WWDC, they basically admitted that they'd tried to cram in too much functionality, by joking that they were considering a Calendar and Web Browser.
This used to be appealing to me, back when the open-source model seemed to be viable even on macOS and Windows. Now any look at the app store will show you apps performing the most basic, should-be (and often is!) bundled, functionality that cost $5 apiece. No slight against developers, who have a right to make a living, but if I just dropped thousands of dollars on a computer and then had to pay $5 for each small convenience feature I wanted, it would definitely be a significant downgrade in experience. I don't live in the Windows ecosystem any more, but the macOS freeware ecosystem has significantly degraded (and it's not just a matter of “I have to use something old”—due to architecture changes, most of the old stuff doesn't work any more, and, understandably, even if the original maintainer is still keeping it up, they now often charge for the product).
But, that's why I think it's great that PowerToys is made by Microsoft. Just because a feature isn't included in the base OS doesn't mean the same company can't create it.
First off, macOS is missing its own features such as three-finger tap to middle click and window snapping, and what you get on Linux is going to vary based on your DE.
Second, building something in adds bloat for people who don't use it and can kill off choices of third-party options that might do the feature (subjectively) better (I still see people mad that Apple killed Sherlock by building their own version of it in)
I like the idea of something pluggable, but also with sane and disableable default features that 98% of users will be totally fine with.
Installing of applications is done by dragging them into some place, and then there is no feedback about what is happening. And so on and on.
Presumably you’ve been a windows user long enough, or at least exposed to Windows enough times to have figured out you can double click a title bar in that operating system and maximize a window, so it’s probably not too far of a stretch to guess you would have figured it out in macOS by simply trying to do the same thing
Agreeably macOS is highly opinionated when it comes to “discovering” some of the hidden interaction features, but come on. You really wouldn’t have had any other way to figure how to embiggen a window without without having to come to HN and read the above comment?
That feels like an extreme example for the sake of being oppositional
The only way to replicate the Windows behaviour of truly maximising is to use third-party tools like Rectangle.
By keeping little toys like this outside of the main Windows feature set, they stay out of the 500 review and design steps, where any of 5000 people can kill the feature.
There’s a lot of politics too. Something like a unmute button may be “owned” by the liaison to the Teams program management, who in turn want universal unmute to be an Azure service that is incorporated into “Azure Live Office Solutions for Windows (Govcloud) for Business E7”.
It can be turned off.
So it should be back to normal!
The clue is in the name "Power" -- it's additional functionality for power users. Since Windows generally caters for the lowest common denominator, features like this would be deemed too complicated (sometimes even dangerous) for some folk. So it is an optional addon for power users.
It's just like how WSL, PowerShell, etc aren't installed by default either.
* PowerToys Awake - Amphetamine
* PowerToys FancyZones - Moom
* PowerToys Run - Alfred
* EarTrumpet - Rogue Amoeba SoundSource
* Windows Terminal - iTerm
* QuickLook - Mac Native Functionality
* Nothing for Windows - HazeOver
* Windows Native Functionality - Bartender
* Snipping Tool - Clean Shot X
* Windows Terminal - iTerm
* Snipping Tool - Clean Shot X
These are not fair comparisons. The Mac tools you list here are much more powerful than the Windows counterparts, and there are good enough built-in alternatives (Spotlight, Terminal and the default screenshot tool).
* PowerToys FancyZones - Moom
This isn't fair either. FancyZones is much more powerful; Rectangle is a better comparison.
(There's also the possibility that there are amazing things I wouldn't use, of course. I have discovered that while I like keyboard shortcuts and Moom's hover dropdown for window resizing/movement, I find "drag a window to the screen edge to resize it" to be a maddening anti-feature.)