Yes and they earned it through gainful employment thereby theoretically contributing the same or more to society…
Second, you're assuming people whose income isn't from employment aren't subject to taxes.
Third, you're assuming consumption is not contributing to society.
Fourth, how do you propose wealthy people redistribute to the masses ?
Five, you're assuming wealth is unproductive. Should wealthy people just hoard their wealth in cash and gold instead of income generating assets?
You seem to be arguing against something the GP didnt actually say.