It's a bit of a balancing act. If you're too ban-happy you'll get an echo chamber (some would say that HN already is one) and if anything goes the trolls drive out serious participants. I think it's remarkable that the discussion here is as good as it is, compared to e.g. reddit or other forums.
There has to be a little room for jokes and sarcasm and "devil's advocacy," as that's part of how real people talk about things.