C-level execs are the bullshit in these stories. They meddled with something that wasn’t broken and this was the result.
So articles like these completely miss the point of the commercial design industry.
The goal isn't sales - never mind brand awareness. The goal is to make C-suite execs feel like they're doing something exciting, and maybe even a little creative.
From that POV I'm sure the Tropicana rebrand was a huge success.
And if a design fails, it's always the agency's fault.