Does liberal bias affect academia? Advancing a deadlocked debate
thomasprosser.substack.com
thomasprosser.substack.com
Really? Isn't one of the skills in debate the ability to argue either side of an issue? Isn't that still a skill valued for increasing understanding and easing communication through empathy?
I'd expect someone to be able to take up the challenge; "even a werewolf deserves legal representation."
But that is not valued by modern academia. Modern academia is the new orthodoxy.
Also, very few people -- the fewest indeed amongst academics -- still believe that "even a werewolf deserves legal representation". These days, it's hard to get people to agree to waiting for an investigation before punishment, let alone a trial.
Bollocks.
I have yet to see any decent univeristy that doesn't have Model UN, Forensics, mock courts, and other debate groups that all practice that skill set.
> a major problem was that we could not find academics who would argue for Leave.
The more sinister read on topic could be that there are professors who would argue "Leave" but recognize it would be career suicide to do so. For examples, see attacks on professors who are not adequately anti-racist[1]
I also want to cite Brian Leiter[2] who while I find his tone childish at times (calling Republicans repugnicans, imagine the blowback if a conservative professor used libtards[3]) but nevertheless he tends to be a staunch supporter of academic freedom
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/princeton-president-asks-board-...
[2] https://leiterreports.typepad.com/
[3] I realize this term is uniquely offensive by it's use of a slur of people with handicaps, but I would argue that that isn't the main thing
And yes, I know UKIP is very responsible for the acidic rhetoric
Don't tell that to the side with a deficit.
I could posit a few things, assuming the intent was 'serious' debate and not just any amateurish attempt to prop up unequal-in-quality ideas:
1. Arguments to support it were so thin, that doing so would look fundamentally poor contextually (e.g. you can make an argument for Leave, but not any of the ones that were used to sell the idea, because logically they were either outright daft, or any arguments that could be used would have exposed underlying emotional, not factual, underpinnings that in light of day would appear either unsavory, or at the very least, self-sabotaging and indefensible under anything OTHER than agit-prop.
2. Given the political media environment, it became a third rail no self-respecting academic would want to touch (e.g. most academics won't argue for flat earth theory even as a mock exercise)
I don't know what drivers for the debates were in play, but I suspect that depending on the seriousness (or lack thereof) would have played a key factor.
There is also the simple idea that arguing for something that has no defensible premises (read: it will improve the economy when it won't, it will secure borders when it won't, etc...but will appeal to certain reactionary political contrivances. As a person who has historically leaned center-right on security and economic aspects, I had the same issue in the US over "the wall", an idea I found deeply stupid, still find even more stupid, and ultimately a boat-anchor that only bigoted imbeciles will support reflexively, regardless of cheaper, more effective alternatives existing...because goddammit they need the theater of 'winning' more than actual effective policy).
The parameters of Brexit are sufficiently well understood by any academic who is involved enough to participate in such a debate. The reason that one finds it so difficult to find a defender for it is that Brexit is not driven by any well-meaning intent and any argument in favour of it is inherently intellectually dishonest and trivial to dismiss.