Elsevier's profits alone could fund all academic publications as open access
svpow.wordpress.com
svpow.wordpress.com
Open-access is still absurdly expensive. $1350 to publish an article in an online journal, seriously? Unlimited length and colour figures in an online journal? No shit. The cost should be exactly $0, since all the actual work like reviewing articles is done by volunteers. I'm sure that many universities and companies would be glad to provide free hosting for papers.
Let me take a stab at the answer: You can publish unedited, dubiously archived, difficult-to-cite, poorly advertised articles without anonymous peer review for the cost of hosting, right now.
Are the peer reviewer getting paid you think and how well? Or could one imagine a situation where you could get them to do it for free for ideological reasons?
Blogs can be peer reviewed at no additional cost.
If one allows comments...
That would be arXiv, would it not?
If the academic community were to rally around open access, and then fail to find (even a lot more than) $500k/year, I'd have to say good riddance. That would take a very special kind of incompetence.
I'd say the latter is far more desirable than the former.
If the standard is an open-access site similar to arXiv, that's where the papers would go. No effort needs to be spent there, and there would be plenty of motivation for people and institutions to meet its modest funding requirements without a massive drive.
The primary costs are support/technical staff and equipment, that would not change.
You'd be surprised.
> The cost should be exactly $0, since all the actual work like reviewing articles is done by volunteers.
Peer reviewers are not the only ones working on PLOS, it has a pretty big editorial board[0] of 1300~1400 members and a pretty extensive editorial process. I do not claim to know if (let alone that) it is worth $1350/article, but they do apparently waive publication fees for authors who can't provide them, so the idea is that granted authors pay for insufficiently funded authors.
There are costs to a scientific journal, which have to be covered one way or an other. In an open-access journal, they clearly can't be covered by the one who accesses the information, so they have to be covered either by the one who publishes it (the author) or a third party (via grants).
> I'm sure that many universities and companies would be glad to provide free hosting for papers.
I'm not sure that's got any relevance.
[0] http://www.plosone.org/static/edboard.action#sectioneditors
Maybe it's excessive, and would either reduce over time, or the organisation would find some way to grow into the budget (now, which is more likely?), but the important part would be organising it as a non-profit.
Putting the cost onto the submitter to pay for free access to everyone thereafter is a nice model - academics need those publications to justify their grants, and can allocate money towards it. The problem is, "in perpetuity"[1] is a long time, so you're gonna end up front-loading the cost a bit.
[1] Or maybe just a standard copyright term. Someone still needs to host it though, and preferably keep as much metadata as possible attached.
As other commenters have pointed out, PLoS do have costs. What's easy to overlook here is not just the editorial work and infrastructure costs associated with the articles that are published, but also the costs of assessing the articles that are _not_ published -- that don't make it through review.
I'm not necessarily defending the specific price-point they've set, but I do think it's important that they (and other academic publishers) are free to set a price that works economically: then they can compete with each other on price and features, and, presto, we have an actual _market_. Whereas what we have now in academic publishing is largely a cartel.
The great thing about PLoS is that they have shown, and are showing year on year, that you don't in fact need charity to be a successful open-access publisher. All the whining in the world from Elsevier and Springer about how they need to charge absurd access fees -- all that whining is shown to be nonsense by the example of PLoS.
Finally, it's important to note that PLoS offer no-questions-asked full waivers of the publication fee, so that researchers without institutional funding are not discriminated against. They're a non-profit: their basic goal is not to "increase shareholder value" but to help disseminate science.
Unfortunately, it doesn't break down the operating expenses of $12.21M (2010) with any more granularity than $6.68M on direct publishing expenses, $5.465M on operational expenses and $65K on advertising & marketing.
I would argue the cost of having walled-garden publications is much higher than anyone thinks, considering that currently we can't build any data mining tool to facilitate research. It's such a bad situation that, if i was a creationist, that's the argument i would use against science. Incidentally, i was just trying to download an article. The journal said my chrome browser wasn't supported , then when i tried Firefox, it insisted that i needed to update my version of java (??) to use their freaking downloader to download the paper. Result: paper ignored. [Edit: here it is http://www.scopus.com/record/display.url?eid=2-s2.0-00339652... ]