However, while I can’t say either way if she’s good at other things or not, the headlines aren’t going to answer that either way — news only covers emotionally charged events, and outside science, tech, and weather forecasts, that in turn makes everyone look bad most of the time.
Go live in the south of Germany and see how conservative it is - no card payments, little online delivery, a huge amount of bureaucracy, etc. And the EU forces that sort of bureaucratic conservatism on the whole of Europe, even though some countries like the UK, Sweden, Netherlands, Denmark, etc. are much more liberal and technologically progressive.
https://ec.europa.eu/food/plants/genetically-modified-organi...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food_in_t...
Indeed, the reason I as a vegetarian can have hard cheese is the use of GM bacterial rennet (not a crop, no idea how that changes the regulation rules).
As for card payments, even in Berlin they are less common than in the U.K. prior to Brexit, but that variance by itself (and the increasingly cashless orientation of Sweden) demonstrates the EU isn’t being held back by German skepticism of non-cash money.
Likewise in reverse (and to show this isn’t just an EU thing), when I visited California, I was shocked by how primitive and backward the payment systems were, especially given California has a reputation for being technologically progressive.
However, even if I were to accept all of your claims, this makes little difference in either direction to my opinion of specifically Ursula von der Leyen, as questions of competence are a separate axis to each of liberty-vs-rules and dynamic-vs-conservative and left-vs-right.
Edit: also, GDPR is in this context basically the same as the UK’s Data Protection Act 1998, it is just that nobody outside the U.K. paid any attention to the U.K. acting alone.
That is a simplification but it mostly works like that.
So, the European Commission is not a democracy, it strictly speaking an oligarchy.
The European Parliament is different. But the BIG money is managed by the EC.
Mind you, there's plenty about the European Parliament itself that could also use some improvement. They're still moving between Brussels and Strasbourg every month, for example.
Still I'm wholly in favor of giving more power to the parliament.
However the real problem is political capital, if parliament wanted to they could just refuse to adopt any law or budget etc unless X member of the commission resigns or Y bill is proposed by the commission. The power is there, and this is essentially how parliaments evolved over history, wrestling power away from the monarchs (or in this case they'd be wrestling power from the heads of government in the European Concil)
But because the EP lacks visibility and people are generally uneducated in how the EU works the MEPs won't take the risk even if they felt it was needed and they will hardly be punished for not taking it because people vote MEPs in based on national politics and not their positions in the EU
There aren't really more powers to be given to the parliament, you could make censure of the commission being 50%+1 instead of 2/3 and letting them officially initiate legislation, but those are minor changes and won't change the underlying awareness problem
Even in this thread on a platform on which you'd expect people to be reasonably educated and capable of googling before commenting half of the comments about what the EU and institutions can do are completely uninformed
Even the article in the submission is attacking the European Commission by discussing claims made by an organization entirely distinct from the EU
(The EC draft is deserving of many attacks but it has enough wrong in it not to require bringing in something entirely unrelated)
For instance this last commission took office in december rather than September/October because there was a huge delay in picking the President and then parliament blocked two/three (don't remember exactly) commissioners so new candidates had to be chosen from those countries.
So would you say that for example....prime minister of UK is not democratically elected? After all, you never vote for them - you vote for the party in parlimentary elections, then the party selects a representative to be the prime minister. How is that different?
There is no citizen vote to form a parliament which then will vote for the EC leader. At all. Not even near. It has nothing to do with a representative parliament, really.
We do not know who, why, from where the next EC leader will be. At all.
At least when you vote for a party (in UK, Spain, whatever), you have some idea what person they will vote for Prime Minister.
Nothing of the sort in the EC.
Again, such mechanism exists in nearly all EU countries - you have comissions proposing laws, then parliments pass(or reject) them. The comissions don't need to be voted in by the populace, because the final say is given to people who were voted in.
That is the trick of the name.
The European Commission "sounds" as the "Commission for highways" in the, say Ministry for the Interior. But it has nothing to do with that AT ALL.
It is the main government branch of the EU, the "executive". Despite its name.
The parliament is just the "legislative".
That is the trick they played on us. And, honestly, part of what made British brexiters mad at Europe (not trying to be on either side, hey).
In the case of the EU the government is usually (always?) composed by members of the winning EU party, which are politically aligned coalitions of national parties.
[0] Not just republics, also constitutional monarchies
[I'm used to Italian politics, but I get the feeling that UK is pretty much the same]
Turns out our system, while based on the same basic principles evolved in a very different way from the UK/Germany etc
For the UK the main difference is that most of their governments are majority governments, due to their electoral system either labour or the tories are going to have (in 90% of cases) an outright majority, so the government (at least the PM) is going to be pretty much known as soon as the election is over
In germany/the netherlands they have more often coalitions so you don't know until after the parties have negotiated post-election. This is closer to what we have in italy, however there are two differences:
1. There are strong conventions about the larger party taking the head of government position, something like what happened with the Conte I government where two parties agreed on a government but had to bring in a "neutral" PM does not happen abroad
2. Governments are more likely to last the length of the mandate, specifically it's quite rare to have governments fall and bring in a "governo tecnico" headed by a neutral PM
So turns out that other countries are much less used to have the PM be someone that hasn't campaigned at all
A third difference, in which italy is quite unique amongst parliamentary systems, is that both chambers have to give their confidence, almost everywhere else it's just the lower house, while in italy also the Senate must agree to a government.
This is similar to how the European Council also has to agree on the EU commission members but very unlike other countries, where the upper houses are at worst symbolical and at best very constrained in their powers
Regarding the Council (assuming you are referring to the council of the EU), that's certainly an institution I would like to see reformed as it is a body with legislative powers composed by executive members.
> Council (assuming you are referring to the council of the EU)
I was actually referring to the European Council, since it's the organ that is involved in the election of the Commission
But agreed on the national executive branches legislating at the EU. That is at the same time the most undemocratic thing about the EU and the least common criticism, which I find baffling
Personally I'd rather the council operated as a parliamentary assembly made up of delegations from national parliaments / national parliamentary committees
I just don't want it to be directly elected too, the US made that mistake with the 17th amendment and I always get the feeling they're worse off for it
As mentioned elsewhere, that's not the case. The PM has always won at least two votes, one in their constituency (winning a local election) and another from their party membership.
What you really mean is, there has been no universal vote on the choice of PM themselves, which is correct. It's not a presidential system. However, that doesn't mean they never won a vote.
In contrast, the EU is run by people who have never actually won a vote. Or, well, technically von der Leyen won a "vote" in the EU Parliament but she was the only candidate who was on the list, so "winning" only meant reaching the quorum threshold.
I do want to say however that this argument about the double election you make doesn't really hold much water in my opinion. It is obvious that the UK institutions have a more developed democratic tradition than the EU ones
But they do not lay in the PM having to be an MP nor in the parties using a primary to choose their leaders
An MP is elected on the basis of their constituents thinking they'll do a good job as their representative, not as a way to find the most capable person in the country to be PM, so it's not a relevant election to gain legitimacy as PM, in the same way UvdL being an MP in the bundestag for 10 years prior to becoming commission president doesn't improve her legitimacy as EC president
As for the party vote, that is a good system and I do wish they'd gone with the spitzenkandidaten (more so we could stop having this conversation than any practical reason or love for Weber), but in this case it'd have been more undemocratic, not less
Weber, much less Timmermans or the Renew people, had no outright majority in the parliament and no majority in the Council, and the council has its own legitimacy even if its made up of (mostly) indirectly elected individuals. Members of the EUCO have more visibility and their actions are under much greater expectations of representing popular will than any single MP or MEP
I fail to see the democratic appeal of a majority of voters (whose MEPs and leaders didn't think Weber was a good fit) having their voices ignored because Weber won a vote within a private organization
But that might also be because where I'm from the expectation is for government to represent a majority rather than a plurality
> "vote" in the EU Parliament but she was the only candidate who was on the list, so "winning" only meant reaching the quorum threshold.
I was under the impression you were from the UK, so I apologize if I assumed familiarity with the parliamentary system in my comments above
In parliamentary systems (which the EU kinda is with some differences) after an election the Head of State consults with the parties to find who would be able to form a government and then once it reaches a decision the individual in question asks Parliament for their confidence and if parliament gives it (so a majority votes yes) then they are "elected"
In the EU's case the only peculiarity is that instead of the Head of State being an individual it's the European Council acting by QMV
Even after reaching the quorum if a majority in parliament had voted No to UvdL she wouldn't be Comission president
I'm not sure they were asked to vote yes/no. They were asked to vote for who should be Commission President, but there was only one name on the list. They could either vote for her or refuse to vote at all.
The relevant parts of Article 17 TEU (link below) are:
> the European Council, acting by a qualified majority, shall propose to the European Parliament a candidate for President of the Commission
> This candidate shall be elected by the European Parliament by a majority of its component members
> If he does not obtain the required majority, the European Council, [...], shall within one month propose a new candidate who shall be elected by the European Parliament following the same procedure
There was only one name on the "list" because there was no list, the question was to approve or to send back for a different name (got relatively close actually if 10 more MEPs had abstained/voted against/not showed up she wouldn't have been elected)
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A...
guess who ended up being appointed leader? someone who didn't take part and wasn't even part of the process
it's a complete farce, and the powerless parliament is only there to give the entire the thing the appearance of being democratic
What makes you say it's powerless? I'm genuienly curious. In my opinion it's the comission that is completely powerless - it can't do anything without the parliment agreeing, and the parliment is under no obligation to agree with them.
If you mean that the "laws"(they aren't laws technically) don't apply anywhere until actually accepted and adopted by the EU member states - then yes, that's very much by design.
yes, that's the point
The EU parliament votes on new EU 'laws' as a part of ordinary legislative procedure. It can reject laws or amend them. But contrast to national parliaments, it cannot propose new laws.
The truth is that even on national level, most laws are proposed to parliament by government, not by MPs.
> If you mean that the "laws"(they aren't laws technically) don't apply anywhere until actually accepted and adopted by the EU member states - then yes, that's very much by design.
That is not true, there are directives and regulations (as EU 'laws'). Regulations apply directly, without any adoption by members states. Directives have to be adopted, but member states are required to adopt them and in some border cases they apply even if not adopted.
Correct. The EU Parliament calls itself a Parliament, but isn't.
1. He had to get elected MP in his constituency.
2. He had to win a vote by the Conservative party membership (anyone can become a member).
Both the big parties in the UK have some degree of internal democracy for choosing their next leaders. It's true that it's not a presidential system, but it's not comparable to the Commission where the commissioners haven't won any votes ever (the GP post sort of implies there's a vote amongst national leaders but we honestly have no idea how vDL was selected - maybe there was no vote at all and it was all some sort of stitch-up).
It is also my understanding that it's purely because they chose to do that. They only need to name a prime minister, how they decide on one isn't defined by law.
>>He had to win a vote by the Conservative party membership (anyone can become a member).
Again, the point is that the PM is chosen not by the general populace, they are selected within the winning party.
>>but it's not comparable to the Commission where the commissioners haven't won any votes ever
The commission is comparable to the House of Lords at best, where the people aren't elected either - both of them only advise the parliment though, neither the EC nor the house of lords can pass any laws by themselves. That's why it's "allowed" - the Comission has no real power because it relies on Parliment(which is democratically elected) to make the final decisions.
This is sort of true but misleading, the PM is the leader of the winning party, and the leader is always chosen before an election, so the electorate know exactly who will be PM when they vote.
[0] although I’ll accept he doesn’t really count because both he and the Conservative party explicitly said prior to that election that if you vote for Blair you’ll get Brown soon after.
No, but that's not relevant to the original point.
The two big parties are big and old because they are stable yet also able to change to reflect the changing electorate. They probably wouldn't have survived so long if they weren't internally democratic. The same is true in the US, the two big parties remain big because they're more like loose coalitions with a lot of internal democracy, hence why party elites are constantly getting upset about 'takeovers' by outsiders like Sanders, Trump, the tea party etc.
"The commission is comparable to the House of Lords at best ... the Comission has no real power because it relies on Parliment(which is democratically elected) to make the final decisions."
You've got it backwards. The EU Parliament is like the House of Lords. Both can propose amendments to legislation and slow things down, but they can't actually propose new law changes. In the UK only Parliament can initiate the process of changing the law, and in the EU only the Commission can. They call this the "right of initiation". The power to amend is also a lot less useful than it looks, because if the EU Parliament amends something in a way the Commission doesn't like, they can just revoke the law change completely and try again. The Commission is never required to accept an amendment.
In practice the EU Parliament usually amends laws to give the EU even more power than it was already writing in for itself. Because the EU Parliament isn't really a parliament, the sort of people who run for election are the sort of people who are content to either cheer or boo from the sidelines. That's why none of the EU level parties have any distinguishable policies beyond "support the EU in whatever it already wants to do" and "leave the EU/slow it down". Most of them are cheerleaders.
I’ll be happy to say the UK also doesn’t count as a “proper democracy”, but counting it as more democratic than the EU feels like arguments-as-soldiers.
My personal take is that the EU is a trade agreement that, unlike most trade agreements, has at least a modicum of democratic accountability. But the foundation of its democratic nature is the member states within the EU rather than the supernational coordination organisation itself, which is precisely as democratic as its members want it to be and no more nor less than that.
And if parliament votes no, the EU Commission can always reintroduce the legislation, perhaps dressed slightly different, until the parliament votes yes. Which is the modus operandi of the Commission as described by Juncker in the past:
> We decide on something, leave it lying around and wait and see what happens. If no one kicks up a fuss, because most people don't understand what has been decided, we continue step by step until there is no turning back.
In a parliamentary system the legislature picks the prime minister (executive), therefore the coalition now controls the executive branch too.
Now the executive branch appoints someone to the EU commission. The EU commission holds legislative power in the EU.
EU parliamentary elections pick MEPs. The successful national parties are going to find now success in MEP elections, because they're already successful locally.
This same national party is part of an EU-wide along with other similar parties from other EU nations. The elected MEPs will have EU-party affiliations based on that.
Or in other words, it's the same groups of people in power on all of these levels.
I'd also argue that maybe child abuse in Europe is below the global average, so we may be talking about orders of magnitude wrong, not just slightly.