Not without changing our voting. The equilibrium point of our choose-one, winner-take-all plurality voting system naturally cultivates two-party dominance.
I know, that's why I ask: is such a voting system possible?
Cardinal voting methods eliminate the spoiler effect, which is one of the biggest obstacles that 3rd party candidates face right now. It would let people support any number of alternative candidates without detracting from their support of "safe" candidates.