Solar is the ultimate option of energy independence, since as the OP discusses, 30 lbs of sand turned into solar cells will power a house for three decades or more.
Solar is the ultimate option of energy independence, since as the OP discusses, 30 lbs of sand turned into solar cells will power a house for three decades or more.
Solar will likely be some part of the answer but it's always going to be niche relative to oil, coal, nuclear, and (where the region allows it) geothermal/hydroelectric.
The question that only experts in the space could answer is whether the $1.25 price per Watt is due to a real decrease in the price of fundamental components/manufacturing processes or whether it is due to subsidies of some kind.
[1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/comment/ambroseevans_prit...
[2] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/business/global/25chinasid...
The OP graph showed solar prices falling faster than linear on a log scale. Meanwhile, nuclear and coal plant construction costs are now two to three times what they were a few years ago.
Not sure where your confidence solar will be a niche player comes from when the pricing trends favor solar so dramatically.
There is no way around the fact that the sun doesn't shine 24 hours a day, and residential power usage peaks after dark.
In short, other types of large-scale generation will always outdo solar because it just cannot reliably provide power around the clock.
A bicycle is cheaper than a car by an order of magnitude, but can't carry passengers or luggage, can't go long distance, and isn't weatherproof. That's why nearly everyone with a bike also has a car, even despite the massive cost advantages to cycling.
First, however, residential usage does not peak after dark. Peaks occur on sunny hot days when A/C usage is maximum. And since in the US the electric grid already exists and no one is proposing dismantling it, that simplifies the problem.
Ten years in the future, iPad-level power consumption will rule for computing machinery at home (iPad == 2.5 watts). LED lights will be common. Solar panels will be the cheapest form of electricity, if current trends hold. Even on a cloudy day, solar PV generates significant power, so about the night?
Batteries, either connecting a city's worth of hybrid cars, dedicated battery packs, pumped water storage, compressed air storage, are all options. Others are to run natural gas generators at night, or wind or hydro or geothermal, all grid connected. None of these are particularly difficult to imagine, and combined with efficient lighting and other expected improvements in efficiency could easily be expected to cover residential night time load.
Adding battery packs significantly increase the cost of a system by an order of magnitude. These are all true but they do not factor cost into the equation. With any of these additions, solar will still be far more expensive than baseload grid power, and for most will still not negate the need for a grid connection.
All these technologies will be fantastic for remote areas to obtain a higher standard of living, but essentially have zero chance of displacing baseload grid power as the majority of power usage in urban areas.
The only way they will win out in the long run is with punitive taxation of large-scale power generation, which is essentially a political dead end for all those who try it.
It's great to be enthusiastic about solar power, I personally like solar technology and will buy when it makes sense to do so on it's own merit. But there are limitations that are very difficult to overcome.
At current prices. Grid-scale batteries are expensive now because each is a unique specialty product. If we built sodium-sulfur batteries in the same volume as we build gasoline storage tanks, the price would decrease dramatically.
Efficiency gains also matter, because net system efficiency is a geometric process. Consider a 20% efficient solar cell and a 20% efficient battery: the system efficiency is a ghastly 4%. And that's not counting power conversion and transmission.
If the solar cell and battery were boosted to 40% efficiencies (physically possible), then the system efficiency would rise to 16%, a factor of 4 increase. That's halfway through the order of magnitude price problem you give.
Then there's heating and cooling efficiency. American buildings and refrigerators tend to have horrible insulation. In many localities, merely using proper insulation closes the rest of the price gap.
As a data point, I sized the batteries at my cabin to provide two days of power under total cloud (more than enough for getting to 24 hour solar power) and the batteries cost about half what the panels did.
(That discharges the batteries to 60% capacity. You also need to consider that the batteries will last about 6 years then get recycled. I mentioned AGM because they can charge much faster. If you are only interested in 24 power shifting, it might be cheaper since you'd need to buy more capacity in lead acid batteries to tolerate the charge rate. )
The question raised was could solar PV supply a majority of residential electric load if it was basically unavailable at night.
In ten years, when the OP expects solar PV to be cheaper than all other forms of generation, how much power will really be needed at night?
I can easily imagine a house with very little night time consumption. Natural gas furnace, gas stove, gas water heater and dryer; nothing exotic. Refrigeration electric load can be shifted to the daytime by simply setting the controller to over-chill the freezer during the day.
That leaves computing devices, lighting, and entertainment for the night time electric load.
Maybe we can totally flip culture on its head by going to work when it's dark and enjoying the few hours of sunlight all to ourselves.
And I didn't either. I just said Solar will always remain niche because of the inherent characteristics of it. You can't make the sun shine 24 hours a day, day in, day out and create baseload power. You can add capacity and use storage, but you'll never be able to make it competitive as you do so, because your efficiency drops as you do. You can be passionate about solar, but you can't ignore the facts.
>Hydroelectric power provides a huge amount of baseload for some regions already.
Agreed. Hydro is a fantastic power source and should be expanded because it brings water supplies and electricity, two of the building blocks of civilisation. And this has nothing to do with solar.
>when load is much lower because industrial users use far more power
Large industrial users like aluminium smelting will run whenever the power is cheapest. If that means smelting at night, they will. Worker overtime is a fraction of the savings they will make through cheaper power Aluminium is literally congealed electricity. Again, nothing to do with solar, but I thought I would add it.
Bottom line ; solar will always remain niche, it will have an important part to play in sunny regions where it correlates well with power usage for cooling, but it will never displace baseload power generation by other means.
In the US, 2.5% of baseload power is pump-hydro. Most of this is probably powered by hydro electricity, but solar is working well in many places too.
Sure it does; we just need to blanket the planet in superconductors, and. . . .
Note I am not against government spending for basic research it has paid for itself time and time again.
If you consider solar to the "ultimate option" you're closing your mind to other ideas.
People have made fortunes betting against conventional wisdom.