This is wrong. C++ wasn't based on Smalltalk. It was inspired by ideas in Simula, which predated Smalltalk. Alan Kay tried to convince people (and succeeded with many) that he owned the term object-oriented, because he was the first person to use it. He wanted it mean only his ideas, but from very early on people were applying it to a variety of ideas that were developing concurrently in the sixties and seventies, his being only one flavor among others. He never gave up trying to convince people that all the other competing ideas were a distorted, mistaken version of his own, but the truth is that those other ideas had their own history and earned their success on their own merits.